Putting Leviathan in Perspective; L. W. Reed

Ideas and Consequences. Putting Leviathan in Perspective "The Budget Is Out Of Control!" screamed the headline. "As ifits sheer size and momentum had made it untouch able," the writer declared, "nobody seems able to eliminate the waste that everybody recognizes. ' , That may sound like a story that describes the federal government in 1995, but it actu ally comes from a cover story in Fortune magazine of 45 years ago. Published in 1950, the article went on to state, "By any sane economics, Congress should . . . unmerci fully sweat down the $42.4 billion that Mr. Truman plans to spend in the year ending July 1, 1951." A dozen years and two presidents later, the federal budget was a few cents short of $100 billion. Today, at about $1.6 trillion dollars, the federal budget is still eight times larger than it was in 1950 after adjusting for inflation. Appropriations bills are com monly hundreds of pages long, in stark contrast to the very first one after the adoption of the Constitution, which was a mere 111 words.

Don't let these figures slip by without comprehending the magnitude of their meaning. Ifthefederal government were the same size today as it was in 1950, it would be spending 1/8 as much as it is-or about Lawrence W. Reed, economist and author, is President of The Mackinac Center for Public Policy, a free market research and educational organization headquartered in Midland, Michi gan. by Lawrence W. Reed $200 billion. Does anybody out there really believe that today, we are eight times better governed, eight times better off, than we were 45 years ago? We now have a government in Washing ton that practices forcible redistribution of wealth on a scale unprecedented in Ameri can history, makes war on private property, sacrifices the long-run good for the short run "fix," taxes and regulates beyond rea son and then wonders why people don't work as hard or produce as much, squanders billions on things that nary a soul would willingly spend a nickel of his own money for,.and uses its power of the purse to bully the very people who earned the purse in the first place.

While the Congress grapples with the need to curtail Washington's longstanding spending addiction, some partisans would have you believe that a massive, heartless bloodletting is taking place. Rarely will you see on the nightly news anything that even begins to put the gargantuan federal levia than in perspective. If the American people were provided the information they need to fully comprehend how much government they've bought over the years, they might regard most current efforts to cut spending as rather timid. And I haven't even men tioned the phenomenal growth of state and local governments. Economist Stephen Moore of the Cato Institute recently assembled some impres sive data on the growth of government and passed it on to the Senate Budget Commit497 498 THE FREEMAN • AUGUST 1995 tee. Government, he showed, is America's # 1 growth industry. 1 Moore advised the committee that more Americans today are employed by govern ment than by the entire manufacturing sec tor of the U.S. economy. With all the money that local, state, and federal governments will spend this year, you could purchase all of the farmland in the United States, plus all of the assets of the 100 largest corporations in America. If the federal government alone were an independent economy in and of itself, it would be larger than the entire gross domestic product of every nation in the world except for Japan and Germany.

Incredibly, the $2.5 trillion that local, state, and federal governments will spend this year represents $24,000 per household in America. Adjusted for inflation, that's up from about $13,000 per household in 1960. Moore asks, "Are government services twice as good today as they were in the 1960s1It is no accident that as government has grown larger over the past four decades, there has been a steady erosion in the percentage of Americans who trust govern ment to do the right thing. In the 1960s, roughly 60 percent of Americans said they had confidence in government 'most of the time,' while today less than 25 percent do. " The next time a brave soul in Congress suggests a spending cut, don't be afraid. The budget cutters are starting out with a gov ernment so big that even if they had their way on everything, there would still be far more government left over than we had barely two generations ago. And somehow, back in those dark days of a mere $45 billion in the federal checking account, we survived. D 1. For an earlier discussion of this topic, see Stephen Moore, "The Growth of Government in America," The Free man, April 1993.

Light a fire for freedom! Launch a Freeman Society Discussion Club! J oin the growing ranks of Freeman readers who have become part of FEE's net work of Freeman Society Discussion Clubs. More than 80 clubs have been orga nized in the 27 states and 5 foreign countries. Leonard E. Read once observed that rancid intellectual soil nurtures an unend ing variety of socialist fallacies and that "finding the right is the key to salvation." FEE is making the right both known and prevalent by launching discussion clubs nationwide, and by providing free literature and speakers to improve understand ing of the moral and intellectual foundation of a free society. Club members receive a number of special benefits, including discounts on FEE publications and invita tions to special FEE events. For more information about starting a discussion club, or joining a Freeman Club that may already be meeting in your area, write Felix R. Livingston, Vice President and Director of Freeman Services, 2814 Hilsdale Harbor Way, Jacksonville, FL 32216, or call/fax (904) 448-0105.