The Liberty Archive FREECAPITALISTS.ORG

Conceived in Liberty Companion · Volume IV, chapter 39 · 16 August 1777

Or Molly Stark sleeps a widow

A lean man in plain clothes strides uphill pointing at a log fort on the crest, while farmers in shirtsleeves with paper in their hats run up the slope behind him, and white smoke drifts from the fort.
Near Bennington, August 16, 1777. General John Stark’s New Hampshire militia, in shirtsleeves with white paper in their hats, close in on Baum’s German dragoons on their hill. As the story goes, Stark tells his men the enemy is theirs or Molly Stark sleeps a widow. Rothbard admires a general who answered only to his state’s General Court. Chapter 39 of Conceived in Liberty.

Download the painting, full size (JPEG)CC BY 4.0

Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0: credit freecapitalists.org. How to credit.

Adapted from Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Mises Institute, 2011), CC BY 3.0.

The story, from several sources

This account blends Rothbard’s chapter with the other sources listed below and has not yet been separated into Rothbard’s own account and the fuller story. Read Rothbard’s chapter 39 for his account.

In August 1777 John Burgoyne, short of food and horses on his march south from Canada, sent about 700 men under the Hessian Lt. Col. Friedrich Baum to raid the stores at Bennington. Baum ran into General John Stark’s militia. Stark had fought at Bunker Hill and Princeton, then quit the army when he was passed over for promotion, and in July the New Hampshire legislature asked him to raise a brigade. He raised 1,500 men, about one voter in ten in the state. Congress’s generals ordered him to join the main army, and Rothbard says Stark flatly refused, answering only to New Hampshire’s General Court, and chose to harass Burgoyne’s supply lines. After a day and a half of rain, on August 16 the militia came at Baum’s hilltop redoubt on Walloomsac, about ten miles from Bennington. Some men approached in shirtsleeves with white paper in their hats, the mark the Germans had been told to expect of Loyalists, and walked in close before the shooting began. Tradition has Stark telling his men they would have the enemy by night or Molly Stark would sleep a widow. Baum was killed, over 350 Germans were captured, and Seth Warner’s 400 men routed the relief column. Burgoyne lost nearly a thousand men.

Where the record differs from Rothbard

Errata notes. Rothbard’s text and his account above are left as he wrote them. Every erratum.

Conceived in Liberty, p. 1324
Rothbard says Baum, “reaching Bennington on August 14”, met Stark’s militia there, and “on the morning of August 16” Stark struck, aided by the shirtsleeved ruse.
The evidence The fight was at Walloomsac, New York, about ten miles from Bennington, on a hill Baum had fortified (the Dragoon Redoubt). The shirtsleeved men with white paper in their hats were Colonel Nichols’s column, taken for Loyalists in the rain at about nine in the morning; Stark’s main assault came about 3 pm on the 16th after the rain cleared. Read through Wikipedia, ‘Battle of Bennington’, the American Battlefield Trust and HistoryNet summaries; the primary reports were not opened.
Source the sources named in the evidence column

Sources

  1. Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Auburn, Ala.: Mises Institute, 2011 single-volume ed.), vol. IV, ch. 39, ‘The Burgoyne Disaster’, pp. 1321-1332. CC BY 3.0. Rothbard
  2. ‘Battle of Bennington’, Wikipedia (accessed 2026-10-02), via a fetch summary: the battle at Walloomsac, New York, about 10 miles from Bennington; Baum’s small redoubt at the crest of the hill; rain for a day and a half; Stark’s assault around 3 pm; the white-paper ruse; Stark’s ‘continual clap of thunder’; the Molly Stark line. Cites Pancake (1977), Ketchum (1997) and Crockett (1921). Secondary source
  3. American Battlefield Trust, ‘John Stark’s Northern Victory’ (accessed 2026-10-02), via a fetch summary: Stark’s men in civilian dress; Nichols’s column mistaken for loyalists; the redoubt of logs and timber housing the dragoons; two three-pounder cannon on raised ground; the attack at 3 p.m.; the Molly Stark line ‘likely apocryphal’. Secondary source
  4. Champlain Valley National Heritage Partnership, ‘John Stark, The Hero of Bennington’ (accessed 2026-10-02): a family description of Stark as ‘of medium height, thin and erect, with light blue eyes and a cold, piercing stare’; born 28 August 1728, so 48 on 16 August 1777. Secondary source
  5. ‘John Stark’, Wikipedia (accessed 2026-10-02): born 28 August 1728; commanded about 1,492 militiamen in civilian clothes with personal firearms at Bennington; accepted his New Hampshire commission on condition that he answer to the state; the Ulysses Dow Tenney portrait (c. 1790). Secondary source
  6. HistoryNet, ‘Battle of Bennington’, via a web search summary (accessed 2026-10-02): Americans in shirtsleeves with white paper in their hats approached Baum’s camp and were taken for Loyalists; Nichols and Herrick flanking the Dragoon Redoubt. Secondary source
  7. srcalifornia.com, ‘Uniforms of the American Revolution: Dragoon, Brunswick Dragoons, Regiment Prinz Ludwig’ (accessed 2026-10-02), via a fetch summary: heavy cavalry boots exchanged for long striped-ticking overalls, the rest of the cavalry dress retained; coat colour not given. Secondary source