The Liberty Archive FREECAPITALISTS.ORG
Companion menu

Selected exploration

What makes resistance legitimate?

Compare a tax refusal, a town’s administrative resistance, and an army mutiny by examining grievances, methods, and consequences.

3 scenes · 13 minutes reading · 30 minutes optional discussion

Prior knowledge: No prior reading of the book. Understand that the Continental Army fought for independence from Britain; each scene explains its disputed obligation.

Before you begin

Begin in Massachusetts Bay in 1632, continue under the Dominion of New England in 1687, and finish with Continental soldiers in New Jersey in 1781. The institutions and stakes change substantially. A town’s refusal to cooperate and armed resistance within an army must be compared with attention to the people affected and the available alternatives.

  1. Watertown challenges a tax levy · 17 February 1632
  2. Ipswich refuses a tax commissioner · 23 August 1687
  3. The Pennsylvania Line mutinies · 1 January 1781

Orientation: Start with a community challenging a tax imposed by the governor and assistants.

Scene 1 of 3 · 17 February 1632 · Watertown and Boston, Massachusetts Bay · Volume I, chapter 19

Watertown challenges a tax levy

Watertown will not pay

Does a tax require the consent of the community expected to pay it?

In a plain timber room, a farmer in a brown coat raises one hand in argument at the end of a table, facing a grave man in black seated behind it with other magistrates, while his neighbors stand behind him.
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Boston, 17 February 1632. The men of Watertown stand before Governor Winthrop and the assistants and argue that paying a tax laid without their consent would bring them and their children into bondage. Rothbard calls it the first tax strike in America. They were made to sign a retraction, yet that year the freemen won a say over taxes. Chapter 19 of Conceived in Liberty.

Before this scene

Massachusetts Bay’s governor and assistants ordered a tax to pay for a fort at Newtown. Watertown was assigned a share, but its pastor and elder urged residents not to pay money imposed in that way. A levy is an official demand for payment. The governor and assistants held taxing power under the charter, the document defining the colony’s government. The conflict concerned who could exercise that power and whether towns needed their own representatives in the decision. Winthrop records the hearing on 17 February 1632, not the levy’s exact date. [1] [2]

Rothbard’s account

In the England the Puritans left, Rothbard notes, the Petition of Right of June 1628 had “denounced taxation without consent of Parliament” (p. 158). (p. 158)

In Massachusetts Bay the charter had the governor, deputy governor and assistants elected by the freemen, but “only twelve stockholders migrated to America, and all were officers of the colony” (p. 161). (p. 161) When 109 settlers petitioned to be made freemen in 1630, the freemen let them in, then emptied the concession “by mendaciously claiming that the charter had put all power into the hands of the Council of Assistants” (p. 161). (p. 161) By keeping the charter’s text from the freemen, he writes, “a dozen Puritan oligarchs managed to keep absolute control of the colony’s affairs” (p. 161). (p. 161)

From the beginning, he writes, the authorities had trouble “from the newly burgeoning smaller towns” (p. 161). (p. 161) At the beginning of 1631, Rothbard writes, “a tax of sixty pounds was levied upon each settlement, to pay for frontier forts at Newtown” (p. 161). (p. 161) The inhabitants of Watertown promptly refused to pay the tax, assessed by the Council of Assistants, “on the great old English ground that no community may be taxed without its own consent” (p. 161). (p. 161) He quotes the protesters, who “eloquently declared” that “it was not safe to pay moneys after that sort, for fear of bringing themselves and posterity into bondage” (p. 161). (p. 161) “Here was the first tax strike in America,” Rothbard writes, “long anticipating the episode in Surry, Virginia” (p. 161). (p. 161)

In 1632 “the government bowed to the strike,” though only “after an apology was extracted from the resisters” (p. 161). (p. 161) The freemen took the power to elect the governor and the assistants, the governor still chosen from among the assistants, and the power to make tax levies. (p. 161) Since direct democracy was now held impractical, that power went to their representatives, two deputies elected from each town. (p. 161-162)

The fight went on: in 1634 the towns forced open the “hitherto secret charter” and found that the lawmaking power was “fully and legally vested in the freemen rather than in the assistants” (p. 162). (p. 162)

Additional context beyond the book

When the warrant for the 8 pounds reached Watertown, the pastor and elder called the people together and told them it was not safe to pay money laid on them that way, for fear of bringing themselves and their posterity into bondage.[2] On 17 February 1632 Governor John Winthrop and the assistants summoned them to Boston, the pastor and elder by letter and the others by warrant.[2] After much debate, Winthrop wrote, the townsmen saw their error: they had taken the governor and assistants for a mayor and aldermen, with no power to tax.[2] They confessed it and signed a retractation under their hands, to be read in their own assembly the next Lord’s day.[2]

Why it matters

Interpretation: The outcome must be considered on more than one scale: the hearing ended in a retraction, while Rothbard connects the wider dispute with later representative control. An immediate setback and an institutional change are different kinds of result. [1] [2]

Examine and discuss

  1. What was the levy intended to fund, and what objection did Watertown raise?
  2. How do Winthrop’s account of the hearing and Rothbard’s account of later changes differ in emphasis?
  3. What evidence would distinguish consent to a tax from compliance under pressure?

Read further and reconstruction

Volume I, chapter 19: The Founding of Massachusetts Bay. The event and its interpretation are supported by the sources below. Pose, expression, lighting, and composition are artistic choices, not a visual record of the event.

  1. Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Auburn, Ala.: Mises Institute, 2011 single-volume ed.), vol. I, ch. 19, pp. 155-163. CC BY 3.0.
  2. John Winthrop, Winthrop’s Journal, ‘History of New England,’ 1630-1649, ed. James Kendall Hosmer, vol. I (New York: Scribner’s, 1908), pp. 73-75 (entry of 17 February 1632, with Savage’s note on the charter).

Scene and complete sources: https://freecapitalists.org/books/conceived-in-liberty/episodes/watertown-strike-1632/

Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. Source text: CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.

Connecting the scenes: Fifty-five years later, another Massachusetts town withholds the official needed to administer a tax.

Scene 2 of 3 · 23 August 1687 · Ipswich, Dominion of New England · Volume I, chapter 56

Ipswich refuses a tax commissioner

Stand for our privileges

When does refusing to administer a rule become a form of resistance?

A very tall man in a black coat stands in the aisle of a plain timber hall with one arm raised, while rows of farmers on benches lift their hands, and a clerk at a table looks up from his quill.
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Ipswich, Massachusetts, August 1687. Andros’s council has ordered every town to name a commissioner for a new tax, with no assembly asked. In the town meeting the Reverend John Wise tells his neighbors to stand for their privileges, and the whole assembly votes, twice, to refuse. Rothbard says Wise, town clerk John Appleton and four other leaders went to jail for it. Chapter 56 of Conceived in Liberty.

Before this scene

The Dominion of New England combined colonies under Sir Edmund Andros. His council governed without an elected assembly and required towns to choose commissioners to help assess a tax. A commissioner was an official assigned this administrative task. Ipswich’s leaders met before the town meeting and opposed raising money without a General Assembly. On 23 August 1687 the town refused to choose a commissioner. Its objection targeted the machinery that would implement the tax, rather than merely a payment already demanded from one person. [1] [2]

Rothbard’s account

Rothbard calls Sir Edmund Andros the perfect instrument for James II’s “grand design to smash all self-government, all local government, in the northern colonies” (p. 402). (p. 402) Where the Dudley government would not tax without an Assembly, Andros “had no such scruples,” and he barred the towns from levying their own taxes (p. 403). (p. 403) Each town was ordered to choose a commissioner to assess and collect his new taxes, and many refused, among them all of Essex County except Salem, Newbury and Marblehead. (p. 405-406)

Resistance centered in Ipswich, where in August 1687 the town’s leaders, “headed by its young liberal Puritan minister, Rev. John Wise, and the town clerk, former deputy John Appleton,” met and decided that it was “not the town’s duty any way to assist that ill way of raising money without a General Assembly” (p. 406). (p. 406) They condemned the order as abridging their “liberty as Englishmen” (p. 406). (p. 406) The next day the town meeting approved this view, refused to elect a commissioner and forbade the selectmen to impose any taxes. (p. 406) Other Essex towns, Rothbard writes, followed this “bold example” (p. 406). (p. 406)

Wise, Appleton and four other leaders were imprisoned and tried, and the mass indictment of twenty-eight Essex leaders “cowed most of the prisoners into submission” (p. 406). (p. 406) The six Ipswich men “remained adamant,” Wise “asserting the privilege of Englishmen according to Magna Carta” (p. 406). (p. 406) They were dragged to Boston for a special trial, with jurors “deliberately selected from among foreigners and nonfreeholders,” before Randolph, Dudley, Stoughton and Usher (p. 406). (p. 406) Dudley told Wise, “you have no more privileges left you than not to be sold for slaves,” and that the laws of England could not follow them to the ends of the earth (p. 406). (p. 406)

After almost a month in prison Wise and Appleton were fined fifty pounds and put under a bond of 1,000 pounds for a year’s “good behavior” (p. 407). (p. 406-407) “Under the lash of the staggering sentences,” he writes, the remaining resistance to the new taxes collapsed, and the next year Andros allowed no more than one town meeting a year (p. 407). (p. 407)

Additional context beyond the book

On the night of 22 August 1687 the selectmen and leading men of Ipswich met at the town clerk John Appleton’s house, and the minister John Wise was with them.[2] Wise was then pastor of the church at Chebacco, and Ipswich tradition remembers him as very tall and strongly built, a man of fine presence and a famous wrestler.[2][3]

The town record opens, “At a Legall Towne Meeting August 23d 1687.”[2] Wise spoke vigorously against a tax laid without a vote of the people’s own representative assembly, and told his neighbors that “we had a good God & a good king and Should Do well to stand for our previledges.”[2] William Howlett, the moderator John Andrews and Appleton spoke too.[2] The town declared itself “not willing to choose a Commissioner,” and the record says the vote passed “by the whole assembly twisse.”[2] Appleton, as clerk, sent the vote on to Usher.[2]

On 14 September Dudley and Bulkeley began the proceedings against the men of Ipswich.[2]

Why it matters

Interpretation: A town can resist a distant government by withholding local cooperation. The arrests and fines that followed also show why a coordinated refusal may be difficult to sustain. [1] [2]

Examine and discuss

  1. Why did the government need towns to choose commissioners?
  2. What costs did the Ipswich leaders face for their refusal?
  3. Compare Ipswich with Watertown: how did the institution imposing the tax and the form of resistance differ?

Read further and reconstruction

Volume I, chapter 56: The Dominion of New England. The event and its interpretation are supported by the sources below. Pose, expression, lighting, and composition are artistic choices, not a visual record of the event.

  1. Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Auburn, Ala.: Mises Institute, 2011 single-volume ed.), vol. I, ch. 56, pp. 402-412. CC BY 3.0.
  2. Thomas Franklin Waters, Ipswich in the Massachusetts Bay Colony, vol. I, Part I, ‘A History of the Town from 1633 to 1700’ (Ipswich: Ipswich Historical Society, 1905), ch. ‘Ipswich and the Andros Government’, pp. 237-241, quoting the town record of 23 August 1687, the depositions of Appleton and French (Mass. Archives, vol. 127) and the Council record; and ‘The Meeting House Green’, pp. 422-423.

Scene and complete sources: https://freecapitalists.org/books/conceived-in-liberty/episodes/ipswich-meeting-1687/

Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. Source text: CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.

Connecting the scenes: Almost a century later, the conflict is within the army defending independence. Soldiers dispute pay and service, and resistance becomes armed.

Scene 3 of 3 · 1 January 1781 · Morristown and Princeton, New Jersey · Volume IV, chapter 49

The Pennsylvania Line mutinies

Justice before obedience

How should soldiers’ grievances be weighed against military obedience?

Content note: The narrative describes an officer killed during the mutiny, emissaries executed as spies, and executions after the separate New Jersey mutiny.

At night in the snow a stocky sergeant strides at the head of a long column of ragged soldiers, one fist raised, behind men hauling a small cannon on ropes, torches burning, rows of log huts behind them.
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Morristown, New Jersey, January 1781. At night, Sergeant William Bonzar leads six regiments of the Pennsylvania Line out of camp behind the artillery they have seized, bound for Congress. They are paid in worthless paper, and they will not serve past their three years. Rothbard praises them for putting justice and liberty above military obedience. Chapter 49 of Conceived in Liberty.

Before this scene

The Continental Army was the force fighting for American independence. By the winter of 1780–81 its soldiers faced unpaid wages and depreciating paper money, meaning money that bought less as its value fell. Pennsylvania soldiers also disputed how long they were obliged to serve. Rothbard describes men who understood their enlistments as three years, while officers insisted they remain until the war ended. The Pennsylvania Line, a group of regiments, therefore faced a conflict over both material conditions and the terms of service. [1] [2]

Rothbard’s account

Rothbard writes that “the main source of the soldiers’ distress was the mammoth and increasingly runaway inflation caused by the indiscriminate printing of Continental paper money” (p. 1395). (p. 1394-1395) Inflation, depreciation, price controls and continued idleness, he says, “caused a massive and increasing hardship” for soldiers paid “in increasingly worthless paper” (p. 1395). (p. 1395)

The winter of the mutiny was as bad as the one before, “and for basically the same reasons” (p. 1397). (p. 1397) The Pennsylvanians were most aggrieved: their three years were up, but the military authorities insisted they stay until the end of the war. (p. 1397) On the night of January 1, 1781, the Pennsylvania Line mutinied, killed one officer, wounded two others and captured the artillery. (p. 1397) In his words, “the men were now determined to run their own lives, and unlike the Connecticut mutineers of the year before, they refused to be awed by higher authority” (p. 1397). (p. 1397) Led by Sergeant William Bonzar, six full regiments demanded discharge for all who had served three years and their back wages, and set out to march on Congress in Philadelphia. (p. 1397) In presenting their grievances, he writes, they were “placing justice and their liberty higher than the fetish of military subordination and obedience” (p. 1397). (p. 1397)

Rothbard says “Congress was wiser than to try to treat these men as traitors and mutineers” (p. 1397), and at Princeton Joseph Reed’s committee yielded to their demands. (p. 1397) Congress agreed to discharge the three-year men and pay the arrears, “with an allowance made for the inflationary loss in value of the paper dollar” (p. 1397). (p. 1397) The “incensed mutineers” handed the two Tory emissaries Clinton sent with offers of back pay and pardon to General Wayne, who hanged them as spies. (p. 1397) Bonzar declined Wayne’s gold reward: his men, he said, were “not entitled to any other reward but the love of our country” (p. 1397). (p. 1397)

When New Jersey regiments followed suit, Washington, who “had wanted to crush the Pennsylvanians but was wary of fighting eight regiments” (p. 1398), sent General Robert Howe, who disarmed them and had two leaders shot. (p. 1398)

Additional context beyond the book

The Line lay in log huts on Mount Kemble, near Morristown, which the Connecticut Line had used the winter before.[2] Captain Joseph McClellan of the 9th Pennsylvania noted that about eight at night men of the 11th began to huzza after drawing half a pint of liquor; about nine a disturbance began in the 11th, with musket fire and a skyrocket.[2][3] The mutineers dragged away the artillery and threatened to turn it on the Ninth and Fifth regiments, firing several shots over their heads to bring them in.[2][3] Captain Adam Bettin was shot dead and two officers were wounded.[2][3]

The Journal of the American Revolution names John Williams of the 2nd Pennsylvania as president of the Board of Sergeants, quoting Joseph Reed.[2] McClellan thought near half the Line was forced away that night; the Journal of the American Revolution counts about 1,500 of 2,473 men, who left “in a regulation-perfect column of platoons under the command of their sergeants.”[2][3]

Why it matters

Interpretation: Resistance within a revolutionary army tests whether a claim to liberty applies to those ordered to defend it. Evaluating the mutiny also requires weighing its grievances, the violence it involved, and the risks to others. [1] [2]

Examine and discuss

  1. What two kinds of grievance motivated the soldiers?
  2. How did negotiation with the Pennsylvania soldiers differ from the response to the New Jersey mutiny described afterward?
  3. Compare the mutiny with Ipswich’s refusal: which differences in means and consequences affect your judgment?

Read further and reconstruction

Volume IV, chapter 49: The End of the War in the North. The event and its interpretation are supported by the sources below. Pose, expression, lighting, and composition are artistic choices, not a visual record of the event.

  1. Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Auburn, Ala.: Mises Institute, 2011 single-volume ed.), vol. IV, ch. 49, ‘The End of the War in the North’, pp. 1393-1397. CC BY 3.0.
  2. Michael Schellhammer, ‘Mutiny of the Pennsylvania Line’, Journal of the American Revolution, 14 January 2014 (read in full): the camp at Mount Kemble in log huts the Connecticut Line used the year before; 2,473 officers and men; disturbances about 9 p.m. in the 11th Pennsylvania (Lt. Enos Reeves); a skyrocket and musket fire; four guns seized; Captain Adam Bettin shot dead and two officers wounded; about 1,500 men leaving ‘in a regulation-perfect column of platoons under the command of their sergeants’; Wayne opening his coat; the Board of Sergeants, whose president John Williams of the 2nd Pennsylvania Reed called ‘either very ignorant and illiterate, or was drunk’.

Scene and complete sources: https://freecapitalists.org/books/conceived-in-liberty/episodes/pennsylvania-line-1781/

Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. Source text: CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.

Connect the cases

Use at least two scenes to propose criteria for legitimate resistance. Apply each criterion to the grievance, the available alternatives, the means used, and the consequences. Explain one case where your criteria leave a difficult judgment.

Choose another exploration · Return to all scenes