The Liberty Archive FREECAPITALISTS.ORG
Companion menu

Conceived in Liberty Companion · Volume I, chapter 19 · 17 February 1632

Watertown challenges a tax levy · A plain room in Boston, Massachusetts Bay

Watertown will not pay

Does a tax require the consent of the community expected to pay it?

In a plain timber room, a farmer in a brown coat raises one hand in argument at the end of a table, facing a grave man in black seated behind it with other magistrates, while his neighbors stand behind him.
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Boston, 17 February 1632. The men of Watertown stand before Governor Winthrop and the assistants and argue that paying a tax laid without their consent would bring them and their children into bondage. Rothbard calls it the first tax strike in America. They were made to sign a retraction, yet that year the freemen won a say over taxes. Chapter 19 of Conceived in Liberty.

Before this scene

Massachusetts Bay’s governor and assistants ordered a tax to pay for a fort at Newtown. Watertown was assigned a share, but its pastor and elder urged residents not to pay money imposed in that way. A levy is an official demand for payment. The governor and assistants held taxing power under the charter, the document defining the colony’s government. The conflict concerned who could exercise that power and whether towns needed their own representatives in the decision. Winthrop records the hearing on 17 February 1632, not the levy’s exact date. [1] [2]

Download image

Rothbard’s account

From Conceived in Liberty, chapter 19, pp. 158–162 (2011 edition). Every sentence here comes from Rothbard’s text; the words in quotation marks are his.

In the England the Puritans left, Rothbard notes, the Petition of Right of June 1628 had “denounced taxation without consent of Parliament” (p. 158).

In Massachusetts Bay the charter had the governor, deputy governor and assistants elected by the freemen, but “only twelve stockholders migrated to America, and all were officers of the colony” (p. 161). When 109 settlers petitioned to be made freemen in 1630, the freemen let them in, then emptied the concession “by mendaciously claiming that the charter had put all power into the hands of the Council of Assistants” (p. 161). By keeping the charter’s text from the freemen, he writes, “a dozen Puritan oligarchs managed to keep absolute control of the colony’s affairs” (p. 161).

From the beginning, he writes, the authorities had trouble “from the newly burgeoning smaller towns” (p. 161). At the beginning of 1631, Rothbard writes, “a tax of sixty pounds was levied upon each settlement, to pay for frontier forts at Newtown” (p. 161). The inhabitants of Watertown promptly refused to pay the tax, assessed by the Council of Assistants, “on the great old English ground that no community may be taxed without its own consent” (p. 161). He quotes the protesters, who “eloquently declared” that “it was not safe to pay moneys after that sort, for fear of bringing themselves and posterity into bondage” (p. 161). “Here was the first tax strike in America,” Rothbard writes, “long anticipating the episode in Surry, Virginia” (p. 161).

In 1632 “the government bowed to the strike,” though only “after an apology was extracted from the resisters” (p. 161). The freemen took the power to elect the governor and the assistants, the governor still chosen from among the assistants, and the power to make tax levies. Since direct democracy was now held impractical, that power went to their representatives, two deputies elected from each town.

The fight went on: in 1634 the towns forced open the “hitherto secret charter” and found that the lawmaking power was “fully and legally vested in the freemen rather than in the assistants” (p. 162).

The fuller story, beyond Conceived in Liberty

Not from Rothbard. Drawn from the other sources below; the numbers are those sources.

When the warrant for the 8 pounds reached Watertown, the pastor and elder called the people together and told them it was not safe to pay money laid on them that way, for fear of bringing themselves and their posterity into bondage.2 On 17 February 1632 Governor John Winthrop and the assistants summoned them to Boston, the pastor and elder by letter and the others by warrant.2 After much debate, Winthrop wrote, the townsmen saw their error: they had taken the governor and assistants for a mayor and aldermen, with no power to tax.2 They confessed it and signed a retractation under their hands, to be read in their own assembly the next Lord’s day.2

Why it matters

Interpretation: The outcome must be considered on more than one scale: the hearing ended in a retraction, while Rothbard connects the wider dispute with later representative control. An immediate setback and an institutional change are different kinds of result. [1] [2]

Examine and discuss

  1. What was the levy intended to fund, and what objection did Watertown raise?
  2. How do Winthrop’s account of the hearing and Rothbard’s account of later changes differ in emphasis?
  3. What evidence would distinguish consent to a tax from compliance under pressure?

About the reconstruction

This is an AI-assisted adaptive companion inspired by Murray N. Rothbard’s Conceived in Liberty. It draws on sources beyond the book and is not Rothbard’s original text or a condensation of it. Each scene identifies whether its narration combines sources or separates an account of the book from additional context.

The sources establish the event and accounts of it. The painting’s poses, expressions, lighting, and arrangement are artistic choices rather than a surviving visual record.

Suggest a correction to this companion scene.

Full sources and reuse information

Sources

  1. Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Auburn, Ala.: Mises Institute, 2011 single-volume ed.), vol. I, ch. 19, pp. 155-163. CC BY 3.0. Rothbard
  2. John Winthrop, Winthrop’s Journal, ‘History of New England,’ 1630-1649, ed. James Kendall Hosmer, vol. I (New York: Scribner’s, 1908), pp. 73-75 (entry of 17 February 1632, with Savage’s note on the charter). Primary source
  3. ‘A view of the First Meeting House in Boston. 1632. John Wilson, Pastor’, Digital Commonwealth (accessed 2026-09-29): the first meetinghouse, thatched, stood on State Street and dates from 1632. Secondary source
  4. David Hackett Fischer, Albion’s Seed: Four British Folkways in America (New York: Oxford University Press, 1989), ‘Massachusetts Dress Ways’. Secondary source

Download the painting, full size (JPEG)

Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. How to credit.

Adapted from Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Mises Institute, 2011), CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.

Explore this scene in context

Return to browsing · Companion overview