The Liberty Archive FREECAPITALISTS.ORG

Illustrated Episode · Volume III, chapter 53 · 10 June 1772

The Gaspee burns behind him

Night on calm water: a longboat full of men at the oars pulls away from a two-masted schooner burning on a low shore, its fire mirrored in the water. In the stern a pale man wrapped in a white blanket and dark coat lies back, looking at the flames.
Namquid Point, Rhode Island, June 1772. Shot by the Providence men who boarded his schooner, Lieutenant William Dudingston is rowed toward shore in a blanket as the Gaspee burns aground behind him and her guns go off. Rothbard says the locals could hardly tell his crew from pirates. Britain's answer, a commission that could ship the raiders to England for trial, roused the colonies. Chapter 53 of Conceived in Liberty.

Download the painting, full size (JPEG)CC BY 4.0

Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0: credit freecapitalists.org. How to credit.

Adapted from Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Mises Institute, 2011), CC BY 3.0.

What happened

On the afternoon of 9 June 1772 HM schooner Gaspee, which had spent three months stopping and searching nearly every vessel in Narragansett Bay, ran aground on Namquid Point below Providence. That night John Brown sent eight longboats down the river with muffled oars. About one in the morning, after the moon had set, they closed on the stranded schooner; a shot from one of the boats hit Lieutenant William Dudingston in the arm and groin, and the boarders took his ship. A young medical student bound the wound, and the raiders rowed Dudingston and his crew, some with their hands tied, toward Pawtuxet. He wrote two days later that he was halfway to shore when he heard his own guns go off in the fire. By sunrise the Gaspee had burned to the water's edge. Rothbard sees an officer who "arrogantly stopped, searched, or fired upon everything afloat" (CiL, p. 1017), so that Rhode Islanders could hardly tell his crew from pirates, and a Crown reply worse than the raid: a Royal Commission that could ship suspects to England for treason trials, which he calls a "serious threat to colonial liberties" (p. 1018). The commission sat at Newport in 1773 and named no one. What it did do was push the colonies to set up committees of correspondence, the network that carried the resistance on to revolution.

Sources

  1. Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Mises Institute, 2011 single-volume ed.), Vol. III, ch. 53, 'The Gaspee Incident', pp. 1016-1018. CC BY 3.0. Rothbard
  2. William R. Staples, The Documentary History of the Destruction of the Gaspee (Providence: Knowles, Vose and Anthony, 1845). Prints the documents below; archive.org scan, read 2026-09-29. Primary source
  3. Ephraim Bowen, statement dated 29 August 1839 (a raider, then 86), in Staples 1845, pp. 8-9; same text in John Russell Bartlett, A History of the Destruction of His Britannic Majesty's Schooner Gaspee (1861). Primary source
  4. John Mawney, statement published in the Providence American and Gazette, 1826 (the raiders' surgeon), in Staples 1845, pp. 9-10. Primary source
  5. Deputy Governor Darius Sessions to Governor Joseph Wanton, Providence, 11 June 1772, in Staples 1845, p. 10; his deposition on the drum and the moon, p. 30; his letter of 18 January 1773 on the crew's evidence, pp. 41-42. Primary source
  6. Examination of Bartholomew Cheever, Gaspee seaman, before Deputy Governor Sessions, June 1772, in Staples 1845, p. 11. Primary source
  7. Deposition of William Dickinson, midshipman of the Gaspee, sworn at Boston 11 June 1772, with Admiral Montagu's questions, in Staples 1845, pp. 12-14. Primary source
  8. Lieutenant William Duddingston to Admiral John Montagu, Pawtuxet, 12 June 1772, in Staples 1845, pp. 14-15. Primary source
  9. Examination of Aaron Briggs, 14 January 1773, before the Commission of Inquiry, in Staples 1845, pp. 33-34. Rejected by the commission. Primary source
  10. Examination of Patrick Earle, late seaman of the Gaspee, January 1773, in Staples 1845, p. 35. Primary source
  11. James Sabin to the Commissioners, 1773, in Staples 1845, p. 36. Primary source
  12. Report of the Commissioners of Inquiry to the King, Newport, 22 June 1773, in Staples 1845, p. 54. Primary source
  13. Steven Park, The Burning of His Majesty's Schooner Gaspee: An Attack on Crown Rule Before the American Revolution (Westholme, 2016); excerpt published by the Museum of the American Revolution, 'Read the Revolution', read 2026-09-29. Secondary source
  14. D. K. Abbass, 'Ships of Rhode Island in the American Revolution', essay for the Battle of Rhode Island Association, 2023. Secondary source
  15. Gaspee Days Committee, 'The Gaspee Prior to 1772', gaspee.org (commemorative site; used only where it cites Admiralty records and agrees with other sources), read 2026-09-29. Secondary source
  16. Gaspee Days Committee, 'William Dudingston', gaspee.org (christening date; no authenticated portrait), read 2026-09-29. Secondary source
  17. U.S. Naval Observatory, Astronomical Applications API v4.0.1, 'Sun and Moon Data for One Day', 9 and 10 June 1772, 41.75 N 71.39 W, tz -5, queried 2026-09-29; cross-checked with PyEphem 4.2.1. Secondary source
  18. Matthew Brenckle, 'Clothing the Royal Navy Sailor, 1765 to 1775', Newport Historical Society. Secondary source