The Liberty Archive FREECAPITALISTS.ORG
Companion menu

Conceived in Liberty Companion · Volume IV, chapter 42 · 28 June 1778

The Battle of Monmouth and the Ouster of Lee · open farm country on high ground east of the middle ravine, west of Monmouth Court House, New Jersey

No chance to explain

Under a hot noon sun a tall rider on a white horse thrusts out an arm and shouts at a thin man on a brown horse who shrinks back, while tired soldiers in shirtsleeves file past behind them on a dusty road.
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Monmouth, New Jersey, June 1778. At the height of a stifling afternoon, Washington rides up to Charles Lee at the head of his retreating column, gives him no chance to explain, and curses him in front of the troops. Rothbard sides with Lee: the retreat was needed, the attack was Washington’s order, and Lee’s angry letter led to a court-martial that suspended him. Chapter 42 of Conceived in Liberty.
Download image

Rothbard’s account

From Conceived in Liberty, chapter 42, pp. 1341–1343 (2011 edition). Every sentence here comes from Rothbard’s text; the words in quotation marks are his.

Rothbard writes that, apart from “the reckless General Wayne,” Washington’s generals “agreed with Lee in arguing strenuously against an open attack” (p. 1341). At a council on June 24 Washington suggested a general open attack, and Lee called it “criminal” to risk a general engagement against Clinton’s professionally trained troops (p. 1342). The council settled on “a typically muddled compromise,” a partial attack by 1,500 men that Lee warned could escalate into a general engagement (p. 1342).

Lee refused to lead it and the command went to Lafayette, but when Washington committed 5,000 men, “fully half of his army,” Lee insisted on the command, “the possibility of defeat now being far more grave” (p. 1342). Washington ordered him to attack Clinton’s rearguard to stop Clinton reaching Sandy Hook, “even though neither Washington nor Lee had had time to reconnoiter the terrain” (p. 1342). Clinton had anticipated the attack and stood behind his rearguard with more than 4,000 men; when Lafayette retreated “without authorization,” followed by Wayne and Scott, “Lee had no choice but to retreat,” and he did so “in good order” (p. 1343).

“When Washington, making his advance, met Lee’s force retreating, he gave him no chance to explain the retreat” (p. 1343). “He cursed Lee publicly in a vile manner, halted the retreat, and roused the soldiers to a demagogic pitch” (p. 1343). The battle ended in “a futile draw,” with about 350 casualties on either side, and Rothbard writes that it “accomplished nothing but the loss of lives” (p. 1343).

“The order for attack at Monmouth, over poor terrain, was Washington’s responsibility and his alone,” he writes, and Lee’s “retreat was required by the circumstances” (p. 1343). He calls the outburst typical of Washington’s “habit of passing the blame for his own defeats and blunders onto his hapless subordinates” (p. 1343). Lee’s angry letter led to a court-martial, “subservient to Washington,” that suspended him for a year, and when he denounced Congress for approving “this unjust verdict” he was discharged from the army altogether (p. 1343).

The fuller story, beyond Conceived in Liberty

Not from Rothbard. Drawn from the other sources below; the numbers are those sources.

Washington met Lee at about a quarter to one in the afternoon, on high ground near the Middle Ravine.2 American Heritage puts the heat that afternoon at 96 degrees in the shade, with many men collapsing from exhaustion and thirst.3 Private Joseph Plumb Martin wrote that “the mouth of a heated oven seemed to me to be but a trifle hotter than this ploughed field.”6 Rees quotes a New York volunteer who noted that Lee’s men left their baggage and the soldiers’ coats behind, though Colonel Jackson’s detachment kept its blue coats, and says linen hunting shirts were the preferred warm-weather wear.5

Tradition puts Washington on a white horse and Lee on a brown one, and American Heritage says Washington’s horse was white, but Shoultz writes that no document gives its colour and that Lender and Stone argue from the primary sources for a dark mount.237 Lee answered, “Sir? Sir?” according to Tilghman, and later wrote that he was “disconcerted, astonished and confounded” by his commander’s words and manner.24 He later called Washington’s words “very singular expressions.”2

The American Battlefield Trust treats the later swearing stories as exaggerations by men who were not there, yet American Heritage reports that Hamilton is said to have called it “an awful adjuration” and that Lafayette, many years later, said Washington called Lee “a damned poltroon.”34

About the reconstruction

This is an AI-assisted adaptive companion inspired by Murray N. Rothbard’s Conceived in Liberty. It draws on sources beyond the book and is not Rothbard’s original text or a condensation of it. Each scene identifies whether its narration combines sources or separates an account of the book from additional context.

The sources establish the event and accounts of it. The painting’s poses, expressions, lighting, and arrangement are artistic choices rather than a surviving visual record.

Suggest a correction to this companion scene.

Full sources and reuse information

Sources

  1. Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Auburn, Ala.: Mises Institute, 2011 single-volume ed.), vol. IV, ch. 42, ‘The Battle of Monmouth and the Ouster of Lee’, pp. 1341-1345. CC BY 3.0. Rothbard
  2. Christian McBurney, ‘Did George Washington Swear at Charles Lee During the Battle of Monmouth?’, Journal of the American Revolution, 10 March 2022: the meeting at about 12:45 p.m. on heights fronting the Middle Ravine; Washington on a white horse and Lee on a brown one in the traditional scene; the court-martial testimony of Tilghman, McHenry, Brooks and Lee; Washington’s demand for ‘the reason for this disorder and confusion’; Lee’s ‘Sir? Sir?’, his ‘disconcerted, astonished and confounded’, and the ‘very singular expressions’ letter. Secondary source
  3. The Editors, ‘Washington at Monmouth’, American Heritage 16, no. 4 (June 1965): Washington’s horse ‘actually white’; Hamilton’s ‘an awful adjuration’ and Lafayette’s ‘a damned poltroon’ as reported; the heat, 96 degrees in the shade, with men collapsing; Leutze’s painting, in which Lee ‘sits back in the saddle, his crestfallen face in shadow’. Secondary source
  4. William R. Griffith IV, ‘Major General Charles Lee and the Battle of Monmouth’, American Battlefield Trust (updated 13 April 2021): Lee on a hill near the Rhea farm east and south of the road when Washington found him; Lee’s own account of the exchange, including Washington’s ‘you ought not to have undertaken it unless you intended to go through with it’; the later swearing stories called exaggerations. Secondary source
  5. John U. Rees, ‘That damned blue Regiment: Continental Army Clothing during the Monmouth Campaign’, Appendix M of The New Jersey Brigade at the Battle of Monmouth (revwar75.com, 2003): Lee’s advanced division had no uniform colours; Bernardus Swartout’s note that Lee’s men left the soldiers’ coats behind; Colonel Jackson’s detachment kept its blue coats; linen hunting shirts the preferred warm-weather wear. Secondary source
  6. ‘Monmouth Campaign’, The Liberty Trail (thelibertytrail.org), stop ‘The First Shots’: the oppressive heat of 28 June 1778 and Private Joseph Plumb Martin’s words, ‘The sun shining full upon the field, the soil of which was sandy, the mouth of a heated oven seemed to me to be but a trifle hotter than this ploughed field; it was almost impossible to breathe.’ The work quoted is Martin’s A Narrative of Some of the Adventures, Dangers and Sufferings of a Revolutionary Soldier (Hallowell, Me.: Glazier, Masters, 1830), pp. 93-98, the pages given in Shoultz’s note 2 (see jar-blueskin-2026). Secondary source
  7. Katie Shoultz, ‘Nelson and Blueskin: Washington’s Revolutionary War Horses in the Documentary Record’, Journal of the American Revolution, 3 August 2026: the colour of Washington’s horse at Monmouth not recorded; nineteenth-century paintings showing a gray or white charger; Lender and Stone’s argument from the primary sources for a dark mount; the heat of 28 June 1778. Secondary source

Download the painting, full size (JPEG)

Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. How to credit.

Adapted from Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Mises Institute, 2011), CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.

Return to browsing · Companion overview