The Liberty Archive FREECAPITALISTS.ORG
Companion menu

Conceived in Liberty Companion · Volume V, chapter 25 · 29 September 1787

Absent Pennsylvania legislators are forced into the Assembly · the Assembly Room of the Pennsylvania State House (Independence Hall) on Chestnut Street, Philadelphia

A quorum by force

Can a decision satisfy a procedural rule while undermining consent?

Content note: The narrative describes legislators seized and forced into a chamber; the reconstruction depicts a blocked attempt to leave.

In a tall, plain hall with a raised platform at the far end, a grey-haired man in a torn brown coat lunges toward a side door while townsmen spread their arms to block it, as a thickset man glares from a table.
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Philadelphia, September 1787. The Pennsylvania Assembly cannot call a convention to ratify the Constitution without a quorum, so a crowd drags two absent members, James McCalmont and Jacob Miley, from their lodgings into the State House. When McCalmont bolts for the door, the crowd cries “Stop him,” and the men there block his way. Rothbard calls the seizure a monstrous act. Chapter 25 of Conceived in Liberty, Volume 5.

Before this scene

In 1787 the proposed federal Constitution needed ratification, meaning formal approval, through state conventions. Pennsylvania’s Assembly moved to call such a convention. Opponents walked out, leaving it short of a quorum: the minimum number of members required to conduct business. The dispute was over the process for convening a ratification body, not the convention’s final vote itself. Two absent assemblymen, James McCalmont and Jacob Miley, were brought in by force, allowing the Assembly to proceed. [1] [2] [4]

Download image

Rothbard’s account

From Conceived in Liberty, chapter 25, pp. 221–223 (Volume V, 2019 edition, ed. Patrick Newman). Every sentence here comes from Rothbard’s text; the words in quotation marks are his.

In Pennsylvania, Rothbard writes, the radical Constitutionalists of the interior “promised to be a formidable foe” (p. 221). With a majority of 40-28 in the Assembly, “the conservatives acted with ruthless and indecent haste” (p. 221). On September 28 George Clymer proposed calling a ratifying convention on the day Congress decided to transmit the Constitution, “and hence obviously before the Assembly could have received it” (p. 221). The convention elections were called for “the absurdly early date of November 2” (p. 221). Rothbard calls it “clearly an illegal call for a convention—a call made before the Constitution was even received” (p. 221). The radicals, he says, fought valiantly to refer the matter to the forthcoming Assembly and lost by 43-19; finally, “the desperate radicals walked out of the House as this blocked the quorum needed to set the date and conditions for the convention elections” (p. 221).

“At this point,” Rothbard writes, “a monstrous act occurred that added force to the common Federalist tactic of fraud in the ratification contest” (pp. 221-222). “A Federalist Philadelphia mob (for all urban centers were heavily Federalist) seized two of the radical defectors,” James McCalmont of Cumberland and Jacob Miley of Dauphin, from the mountainous interior, “and dragged them into the Assembly to make a compulsory quorum” (p. 222). The convention election was called, and the radical minority published an address that, he says, formed the basis for the Pennsylvania Antifederalist position.

“The ugly Philadelphia mob threat loomed once again on election night” (p. 222), when a mob pelted the house of the radical Alexander Boyd with stones and threatened to hang the seven noted Constitutionalists who lived there. The October Assembly elections gave the Republicans a majority of only three, yet by the convention elections in early November the Federalists won 46-23, “the same vote by which the convention eventually ratified the Constitution” (pp. 222-223). Rothbard credits the shift to “the superior Federalist organization and propaganda machine, taking advantage of the brief time for debate,” and says more time would have brought greater Antifederalist strength (p. 223).

The fuller story, beyond Conceived in Liberty

Not from Rothbard. Drawn from the other sources below; the numbers are those sources.

On the morning of Saturday, 29 September, the sergeant-at-arms and an assistant clerk were sent to fetch the absent members.4 They found James McCalmont and Jacob Miley at Major Boyd’s house on Sixth Street, and both refused to come.24 A crowd of Constitution men broke into the lodgings, collared the two and pushed them through the streets to the State House.234 They were thrust onto the floor of the House and escorted to their seats, their clothes dirtied and torn, their faces white with anger.23

The roll was called, and the House had its quorum.24 McCalmont, a major in the war, asked to be excused and offered silver for leave to go, and the House refused.23 He sprang up and made a dash for the door, the crowd yelled “Stop him!” and those about the door barred his way.23 Sixteen of the nineteen members who had walked out signed their address, dated that same Saturday, 29 September.4

Jackson Turner Main’s The Antifederalists and Robert L. Brunhouse’s The Counter-Revolution in Pennsylvania give the parallel account of the mob and the quorum.56

Why it matters

Interpretation: Counting enough members establishes one procedural condition, but does not by itself establish voluntary participation. This scene reopens the question of consent after independence, during the creation of a new government. [1] [2] [4]

Examine and discuss

  1. What decision required the Assembly’s quorum?
  2. Why is the forced quorum distinct from the later convention’s vote to ratify?
  3. Connect this case with Rodney’s ride: what difference does voluntary presence make to a representative decision?

About the reconstruction

This is an AI-assisted adaptive companion inspired by Murray N. Rothbard’s Conceived in Liberty. It draws on sources beyond the book and is not Rothbard’s original text or a condensation of it. Each scene identifies whether its narration combines sources or separates an account of the book from additional context.

The sources establish the event and accounts of it. The painting’s poses, expressions, lighting, and arrangement are artistic choices rather than a surviving visual record.

Suggest a correction to this companion scene.

Full sources and reuse information

Sources

  1. Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty, Volume V: The New Republic, 1784-1791 (Auburn, Ala.: Mises Institute, 2019; ed. Patrick Newman), ch. 25, ‘The Battle for Pennsylvania’, pp. 221-230, esp. pp. 221-222 (the haste, the walkout and the mob) and p. 228 (the ratifying vote). CC BY-NC-ND 4.0; adaptation permitted by the Mises Institute, reported by David 2026-10-02. Rothbard
  2. John Bach McMaster and Frederick D. Stone, eds., Pennsylvania and the Federal Constitution, 1787-1788 (Lancaster, 1888), ch. I: M’Calmont and Miley at Major Boyd’s on Sixth Street; the crowd broke into their lodgings and dragged them to the State House with clothes torn and faces white with rage; M’Calmont asked to be excused, offered silver, was refused and made for the door; ‘Stop him’; the first Tuesday in November. Secondary source
  3. ‘Business of the Highest Magnitude’, American Heritage 22, no. 2 (February 1971): the two men collared and dragged to the State House; thrust onto the floor of the House and escorted to their seats; McCalmont, a major, rose and made a dash for the door; ‘Stop him!’; those about the door barred his way; Speaker Mifflin absented himself for a while. Secondary source
  4. ‘The Controversy Surrounding the Calling of the Pennsylvania Convention’, Center for the Study of the American Constitution, University of Wisconsin: the sergeant at arms and the assistant clerk sent for the absent members; a mob brought M’Calmont and Miley to the Assembly; the quorum; sixteen of nineteen seceders signed the address dated 29 September; the election of 6 November and the convention of 20 November. Secondary source
  5. Jackson Turner Main, The Antifederalists: Critics of the Constitution, 1781-1788 (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1961), p. 188: the parallel account of the mob and the quorum. Secondary source
  6. Robert L. Brunhouse, The Counter-Revolution in Pennsylvania, 1776-1790 (Harrisburg: Pennsylvania Historical Commission, 1942), p. 201: the parallel account of the mob and the quorum. Secondary source
  7. Era registry entry new-republic-1784-1791 and place entry assembly-room-state-house-1787 (data/cil/registry/): dress, arms and the chamber; their own sources are listed in their notes. Secondary source

Download the painting, full size (JPEG)

Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. How to credit.

Adapted, with the Mises Institute's permission, from Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty, Volume V: The New Republic, 1784-1791 (Mises Institute), CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. External sources retain their own terms.

Explore this scene in context

Return to browsing · Companion overview