The Liberty Archive FREECAPITALISTS.ORG

Illustrated Episode · Volume III, chapter 56 · 16 December 1773

The monopoly's tea hits the mud

From low on the mud beside a ship's dark hull, men with blackened faces and blankets tip a split chest over the rail, tea pouring onto a heap of leaves and broken boards where bare-armed youths beat it with staves. Torchlit onlookers line the wharf.
Griffin's Wharf, Boston, the night of December 16, 1773. Men with sooty faces and blankets split East India Company chests and pour the tea over the Dartmouth's rail. Down on the low-tide mud, apprentices beat it in with staves. Rothbard calls the Tea Act a bailout: Parliament saved a failing company with a monopoly. Fighting that monopoly was itself a high principle. Chapter 56 of Conceived in Liberty.

Download the painting, full size (JPEG)CC BY 4.0

Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0: credit freecapitalists.org. How to credit.

Adapted from Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Mises Institute, 2011), CC BY 3.0.

What happened

On the evening of 16 December 1773, after Governor Hutchinson refused to let the Dartmouth sail home with her tea, a party of Bostonians boarded the three tea ships at Griffin's Wharf. In about three hours they hoisted 340 chests of East India Company tea out of the holds, split them with hatchets and emptied them over the side. It was nearly low tide, so the leaves piled up on the mud against the hulls until apprentices waded in and beat them down with barrel staves. Most of the disguises were crude: soot or lampblack on the face, a blanket, an old frock. A thousand people stood on the wharf and watched without a sound. Samuel Adams, John Hancock and Joseph Warren stayed at the Old South Meeting House, well away from the wharf. The moon was a thin crescent that set at about eight; the light came from candles, lamps and torches. Rothbard reads the Tea Act as a bailout. Parliament rescued a near-bankrupt East India Company by letting it sell straight to America through a few favored consignees, and he writes that "opposition to a governmentally privileged monopoly is itself a high principle" (CiL, p. 1027). The crowd destroyed only the monopoly's tea and left the ships and the rest of their cargo as they found them, and afterward not one Bostonian would help the governor name a single man.

Sources

  1. Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Auburn, AL: Mises Institute, 2011 single-volume ed.), Vol. III, ch. 55 'Tea Launches the Final Crisis', pp. 1024-1028, and ch. 56 'The Boston Tea Party', pp. 1029-1032. CC BY 3.0. Rothbard
  2. Log of the ship Dartmouth, 28 Nov to 16 Dec 1773, printed in Benjamin B. Thatcher, Traits of the Tea Party (New York, 1835), Appendix, pp. 259-261. Primary source
  3. James Hawkes, A Retrospect of the Boston Tea-Party, with a Memoir of George R. T. Hewes (New York: S. S. Bliss, 1834), pp. 6, 36-41. Hewes's recollection sixty years on. Primary source
  4. Benjamin Bussey Thatcher, Traits of the Tea Party; being a Memoir of George R. T. Hewes (New York: Harper, 1835), pp. 179-186 and Appendix pp. 259-265 (Hewes, Purkitt, Hooton, Sprague and others, recalled in 1835). Primary source
  5. John Andrews to William Barrell, Boston, 18 Dec 1773, printed in Drake, Tea Leaves (1884), pp. LXIX-LXX. Primary source
  6. Massachusetts Gazette and Boston News-Letter, 23 Dec 1773, account of the destruction of the tea, printed in Drake, Tea Leaves (1884), p. LXVIII; with the Boston Evening-Post of 20 Dec 1773, p. LXIX. Primary source
  7. Recollections of Joshua Wyeth (1827), Benjamin Simpson (1830), Peter Edes (1836), Ebenezer Stevens and Robert Sessions, printed in Drake, Tea Leaves (1884), pp. LXXI-LXXX. Late reminiscences; used for physical detail where they agree. Primary source
  8. East India Company to the Earl of Dartmouth, request for compensation, 16 Feb 1774, The National Archives (UK), CO 5/247 (340 chests; 9,659 pounds 6s 4d). Primary source
  9. Francis S. Drake, Tea Leaves: being a collection of letters and documents relating to the shipment of tea to the American colonies in the year 1773 (Boston: A. O. Crane, 1884), Introduction pp. LXIII-LXXXIII. Secondary source
  10. Benjamin L. Carp, Defiance of the Patriots: The Boston Tea Party and the Making of America (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2010), ch. 2, ch. 5 'The Detestable Tea Arrives', ch. 6 'The Destroyers at Griffin's Wharf'. Read through Google Books search-inside. Secondary source
  11. Fred Espenak, Six Millennium Catalog of Phases of the Moon, 1701 to 1800, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center; moon altitude and set computed with PyEphem for Boston, 2026-09-29. Secondary source
  12. National Park Service, 'Boston Tea Party in Real Time' (updated 20 Dec 2023). Secondary source
  13. Nathaniel Currier, The Destruction of Tea at Boston Harbor, hand-colored lithograph (New York, 1846), Library of Congress LC-DIG-pga-08593. The famous image this Episode must not recompose. The LOC item page (loc.gov item 91795889) sits behind a bot challenge, so the Wayback snapshot of 2025-11-30 is cited. Secondary source