The Liberty Archive FREECAPITALISTS.ORG
Companion menu

Conceived in Liberty Companion · Volume II, chapter 27 · 4 August 1735

John Peter Zenger is acquitted · the second-floor courtroom of City Hall on Wall Street, New York City

Three huzzas in the hall

How much can one jury verdict change the limits on criticism of government?

In a packed courtroom, men swing hats and raise their arms as a pale printer grips the bar beside a grave, grey-wigged lawyer, with a stern judge in a white wig watching from the raised bench and jurors standing at left.
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. New York, 4 August 1735. The jury comes back after a brief deliberation, and the crowded hall answers with three huzzas as printer John Peter Zenger stands at the bar beside Andrew Hamilton. Rothbard is cooler than the legend. In his telling the fight was between two factions of the landed oligarchy, and the law of seditious libel “remained virtually intact.” Chapter 27 of Conceived in Liberty.

Before this scene

John Peter Zenger printed criticism of Governor William Cosby and was jailed before his trial. The accusation was libel, meaning a published statement treated as unlawfully damaging to someone’s reputation. His defense lawyer Andrew Hamilton asked the jury to consider both the truth of the articles and the law used against the printer. The dispute also involved competing political factions. Rothbard praises the defense while warning against turning the acquittal into a simple story of permanent press freedom. [1] [2]

Download image

Rothbard’s account

From Conceived in Liberty, chapter 27, pp. 645–647 (2011 edition). Every sentence here comes from Rothbard’s text; the words in quotation marks are his.

Rothbard says historians have been prone to “wild exaggeration” of John Peter Zenger’s trial, “the best-known and most highly touted case concerning freedom of the press in the colonies” (p. 645).

William Cosby’s arrival as governor in 1732 set off a dispute that Rothbard says was “strictly between two factions of the landed oligarchy” over “extremely petty issues” (p. 645). The Morris faction founded the New York Weekly Journal in 1733 with Zenger as printer, and Rothbard calls its attacks “a bracing exercise of the freedom of the press” (p. 645).

Twice refused a grand-jury indictment, Cosby had Zenger arrested for seditious libel on November 17, 1734, and bail of 400 pounds kept him “in prison for nine months before coming to trial” (p. 646). His lawyers were disbarred for protesting Cosby’s packing of the court, and the Morris faction brought in “the venerable Pennsylvania lawyer Andrew Hamilton” (p. 646).

The fight against Cosby “was not at root a popular or liberal affair,” Rothbard writes, but the Zenger case transformed it, for “the popular sympathies were all with the defendant” (p. 646). On August 4, 1735, Hamilton won Zenger’s acquittal by persuading the jury to judge the law as well as the facts and by arguing the articles’ truth (p. 646).

“These were legal advances to be sure,” Rothbard writes, “but they hardly justify the paeans of praise that have been delivered for the Zenger decision”: “the root evil—the common law of seditious libel—remained virtually intact” (p. 646). Truth as a defense is “a very shaky reed,” he argues, and juries guard freedom only when public opinion backs the defendant (pp. 646-647). English law did not accept the jury’s power to judge guilt until 1792, or truth as a defense until 1843 (p. 647).

Perhaps the most important reason to belittle the case, he argues, is that the main threat to the press was the legislature, which punished critics “without benefit of jury,” and that the Zenger case “made virtually no impact on the legislative oppression of the press even in New York” (p. 647).

The fuller story, beyond Conceived in Liberty

Not from Rothbard. Drawn from the other sources below; the numbers are those sources.

The trial was held in the courtroom on the second floor of City Hall on Wall Street, before Chief Justice James DeLancey and Justice Frederick Philipse.34 When Hamilton argued that the truth of a libel was a defense, DeLancey told him, “The law is clear, That you cannot justify a libel.”2

The jury withdrew and came back after a brief deliberation.23 Its foreman, Thomas Bunt in the printed narrative of the case and Thomas Hunt to the New York courts’ historians, answered Not Guilty.23 “Upon which there were three Huzzas in the hall,” the narrative records, “which was crowded with people.”2

Zenger was discharged from prison the next day.23 Hamilton was honored with a dinner at the Black Horse Tavern, and cannon saluted him when he left New York.3

Why it matters

Interpretation: A jury may protect a particular defendant without settling every future conflict over expression. Distinguishing the outcome of a case from a lasting change in law prevents an attractive origin story from replacing analysis. [1] [2]

Examine and discuss

  1. What did Hamilton ask the jury to consider?
  2. Why does the political rivalry matter when interpreting the trial?
  3. Compare Zenger’s acquittal with Bradford’s confiscated press: what protected expression, and what remained vulnerable?

About the reconstruction

This is an AI-assisted adaptive companion inspired by Murray N. Rothbard’s Conceived in Liberty. It draws on sources beyond the book and is not Rothbard’s original text or a condensation of it. Each scene identifies whether its narration combines sources or separates an account of the book from additional context.

The sources establish the event and accounts of it. The painting’s poses, expressions, lighting, and arrangement are artistic choices rather than a surviving visual record.

Suggest a correction to this companion scene.

Full sources and reuse information

Sources

  1. Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Auburn, Ala.: Mises Institute, 2011 single-volume ed.), vol. II, ch. 27, pp. 639-653. CC BY 3.0. Rothbard
  2. [James Alexander], A Brief Narrative of the Case and Tryal of John Peter Zenger, Printer of the New-York Weekly Journal (New York, 1736), the account of the verdict, as reprinted on Encyclopedia.com (accessed 2026-09-30). Primary source
  3. ‘Crown v. John Peter Zenger, 1735’, Historical Society of the New York Courts (accessed 2026-09-30): the courtroom on the second floor of City Hall; Chief Justice De Lancey and Justice Philipse; foreman Thomas Hunt; cheers in the crowded courtroom; the dinner at the Black Horse Tavern and the salute of cannons; Zenger freed the day after. Secondary source
  4. National Park Service, Federal Hall, ‘The Trial of John Peter Zenger’ (as cited in registry/eras/middle-colonies-1710-1770): the trial in the second-floor courtroom of City Hall on the site of Federal Hall. Secondary source

Download the painting, full size (JPEG)

Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. How to credit.

Adapted from Murray N. Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty (Mises Institute, 2011), CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.

Explore this scene in context

Return to browsing · Companion overview