Prior knowledge: No prior reading of the book. The scene introductions explain civil courts, banishment, printing type, and libel.
Before you begin
Follow two Massachusetts Bay dissenters in the 1630s, a Philadelphia printer in 1692, and a New York jury in 1735. Religious teaching, printing equipment, and courtroom procedure are different channels through which ideas could be limited or defended. The sequence compares those channels without treating every case as the same conflict.
May a government punish a belief because it considers that belief dangerous?
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. The woods south of Salem, January 1636. Banished by Massachusetts for denying that magistrates may punish belief, Roger Williams trudges alone through deep snow. He is three days ahead of the men sent to seize him, and they will find his house empty. Rothbard says the great flight south from the Bay began with him and ended in Providence, a haven of religious liberty. Chapter 21 of Conceived in Liberty.
Before this scene
In Massachusetts Bay, religious disagreement could become a matter for civil authorities. Roger Williams challenged their right to punish religious beliefs and questioned the king’s right to grant land belonging to Native people. The General Court, the colony’s governing assembly and court, ordered him banished in October 1635. He could remain through winter only if he stopped spreading his opinions. When he continued preaching, officials ordered him sent to England. His flight belongs to January 1636; its exact day is unrecorded.
[1][2]
Rothbard’s account
Rothbard calls Roger Williams “an individualist and a fearless logician” who “pursued the Puritans’ logic further than they were willing to go” (p. 173). (p. 173) First Williams denied “the right of the civil authority to punish the infraction of religious rule or doctrine,” which, Rothbard says, “struck at the entire theocratic principle” (p. 173). (p. 173) Then he held that the Indians owned the land and the king had no right to grant it, which hit at the Massachusetts charter itself. (p. 173-174)
Forced once to recant, he took up his doctrines again and became Salem’s chief minister. (p. 174) The authorities condemned his views as “erroneous and very dangerous” and punished Salem by refusing it land at Marblehead Neck (p. 174). (p. 174) When he called on the Salem church to separate from the colony’s other churches, it was, Rothbard writes, “the straw that broke the Massachusetts camel’s back” (p. 174). (p. 174) In September the General Court expelled the Salem deputies and jailed John Endecott until he recanted. (p. 174-175)
In October 1635 Williams “stoutly maintained all of his heretical and libertarian opinions,” and the court ordered him out of the colony within six weeks (p. 175). (p. 175) Over twenty Salem families prepared to follow him south and build “a haven of religious liberty” (p. 175). (p. 175) Should he merely move south, the authorities feared, in Winthrop’s words, “the infection would easily spread” (p. 175). (p. 175) The General Court “hastily sent a ship to Salem to arrest Williams and send him speedily back to England” (p. 175). (p. 175) “But Williams bested his persecutors and fled alone into the wilderness,” trudging south through the snow to winter among “the friendly Narragansett Indians” (p. 175). (p. 175)
In the spring he and four friends founded Seekonk, and more Salem families soon followed: “The great southward flight from Massachusetts had begun” (pp. 175-176). (p. 175-176) Plymouth, not daring to displease Massachusetts, banished him again, and across the Seekonk River he founded Providence, where the settlers “scrupulously purchased the land from the Indians” (p. 176). (p. 176) There, Rothbard writes, Williams lived “free and safe in a Providence enjoying religious liberty and separation of church and state” (p. 176). (p. 176)
Additional context beyond the book
Winthrop wrote that Williams had been given leave to stay until spring on condition that he stop drawing others to his opinions.[2] In January 1636 the governor and assistants learned that he was preaching in his house at Salem to more than twenty followers who meant to plant a settlement on Narragansett Bay, and they ordered him seized and shipped to England.[2] At his house they found he had been gone three days, “but whither they could not learn.”[2]
John Barry writes that the winter was so hard a north-east storm froze even Narragansett Bay.[3] Williams recalled that for fourteen weeks he did not know “what bread or bed did mean.”[3] Long afterward he still wrote of “that Winter snow wch I feele yet.”[3]
Why it matters
Interpretation: Williams’s flight turns a dispute over belief into a dispute over the limits of government. Leaving a jurisdiction may offer refuge while imposing serious costs on the dissenter.
[1][2]
Examine and discuss
Identify a belief Williams held that challenged civil authority.
Why was his continued preaching consequential even after the banishment order?
Compare the authority of this court with the Virginia assembly: what can each institution demand of individuals?
What happens to a fair hearing when the governing body also judges its own critics?
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Newtown, Massachusetts, November 1637. Anne Hutchinson stands alone before Governor Winthrop and the General Court, which has just voted to banish her, and asks one thing: wherefore? Winthrop answers, “Say no more, the court knows wherefore and is satisfied.” Rothbard’s point is that the court felt no need to justify itself before reason, natural justice or the public, and refused her any answer. Chapter 22 of Conceived in Liberty.
Before this scene
Anne Hutchinson attracted followers in Massachusetts Bay through her religious teaching. Rothbard connects the campaign against her to the defeat of her allies in the colony’s election of 1637. The General Court combined legislative and judicial authority: the same institution made rules and heard cases. In November it examined Hutchinson and ordered her banished. This was a civil proceeding, distinct from the church proceeding that followed. The surviving examination record should be read alongside Rothbard’s account, because their descriptions of the grounds differ.
[1][2]
Rothbard’s account
Rothbard says Anne Hutchinson’s heresy shook Massachusetts largely because she “occupied a high place in the colony’s oligarchy” and won converts with “rapid and sweeping success” (p. 180). (p. 180) After the Winthrop forces won the May 1637 election by moving it to Newtown, Vane’s defeat “spelled swift suppression for the antinomian heretics” (p. 181). (p. 181) Having “vented their fury on the major followers and isolated the leader,” the oligarchs reached “the culminating point of the drama: the trial and persecution of Anne Hutchinson herself” (p. 181). (p. 181)
“There was no independent judiciary in the colonies”: the legislature, the General Court, was also the highest court (p. 181). (p. 181) In November 1637 her enemies on that court duly “tried” her, convicted her of sedition and contempt, and banished her (p. 182). (p. 182) Only two members dissented, and when Winthrop pronounced sentence she “courageously” asked: “I desire to know wherefore I am banished” (p. 182). (p. 182) Winthrop “refused to answer”: “Say no more. The court knows wherefore, and is satisfied” (p. 182). (p. 182) Rothbard’s verdict: “It was apparently enough for the court to be satisfied; no justification before the bar of reason, natural justice, or the public was deemed necessary” (p. 182). (p. 182)
“Spared banishment during the rugged winter, she was imprisoned at the home of one of her major enemies” (pp. 182-183). (p. 182-183) At her church trial in March even John Cotton “turned on her savagely,” but she had the last word: “Better to be cast out of the Church than to deny Christ” (pp. 182-183). (p. 182-183) In April, “ill and exhausted,” she joined her husband at Aquidneck (pp. 182-183). (p. 182-183)
Additional context beyond the book
Winthrop’s journal has the General Court assembling on 2 November 1637.[3] Her examination opened on 7 November in a thatched-roof meetinghouse, where the nine magistrates and thirty-one deputies of the court sat on backless wooden benches.[4] At one point she seemed ready to collapse, and a chair was called for.[4] When she said she saw the truth “by an immediate revelation” from God, Deputy Governor Dudley announced, “I am now fully persuaded that Mrs. Hutchinson is deluded by the Devil.”[4] John Cotton was not among the two judges who voted against banishing her, and one minister abstained.[4]
The court’s record has Winthrop answering her question, “I desire to know wherefore I am banished?”, with “Say no more, the court knows wherefore and is satisfied.”[2]
Winthrop wrote that “because it was winter, they committed her to a private house,” which Famous Trials places in Roxbury.[3][4] On 1 April 1638 she began a six-day walk south to Providence Plantation, where she boarded a ship for Aquidneck.[4]
Why it matters
Interpretation: The case invites scrutiny of how political rivalry, religious disagreement, and judicial power interact. A conclusion about fairness should use the recorded proceedings, not the painted expressions of the participants.
[1][2]
Examine and discuss
What different powers did the General Court combine?
What does the examination record establish about the grounds for banishment?
Compare Hutchinson’s hearing with Williams’s flight: which choices were available to each dissenter?
Scene and complete sources: https://freecapitalists.org/books/conceived-in-liberty/episodes/hutchinson-trial-1637/
Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. Source text: CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.
Connecting the scenes: Move to Pennsylvania more than fifty years later. Here the authorities act against the tools that distribute a religious argument.
Scene 3 of 4 · summer 1692, before the proclamation against Keith at the end of August · Philadelphia, Pennsylvania · Volume I, chapter 64
The press seizure has no recorded day or month in the sources used here; the narrative places it in summer 1692 before the end-of-August proclamation.
How can control of printing tools restrict public disagreement?
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Philadelphia, summer 1692. Quaker officers carry William Bradford’s press and cases of type out of his shop. The printer, under arrest, stands on his own doorstep and watches them go. His crime: he printed the Keithians’ paper without a license. Rothbard says the Quaker officials, once the persecuted, had become the persecutors. Chapter 64 of Conceived in Liberty.
Before this scene
Pennsylvania’s Quakers divided in 1692 over George Keith’s religious position. William Bradford, a printer who supported Keith, printed the group’s statement. Authorities arrested Bradford and John McComb, who distributed the pamphlet, and confiscated the press and type. Type means the individual pieces used to compose printed words. The dispute therefore concerned both religious authority and the practical means of circulating arguments. Rothbard places the seizure before a proclamation at the end of August; the sources used here do not establish its exact day.
[1][2]
Rothbard’s account
By 1692, Rothbard writes, government had returned to Pennsylvania under Thomas Lloyd, but the colony was “still quasi-anarchic, since no taxes were yet being levied by the government” (p. 486). (p. 486) George Keith, a Scottish Quaker minister, concluded “that all participation in government was counter to Quaker principles” and, Rothbard says, “wished to press on from Quaker nonviolence to pure individualistic anarchism” (p. 487). (p. 487) In the spring of 1692 the Keithians split openly from the standard body of Quakers. (p. 487)
Rothbard asks how the Quakers, “after being persecuted so widely for religious differences,” met a split in their own ranks, and answers: “Unfortunately, not very differently from other groups” (p. 487). (p. 487) The Keithians drew up a statement of their position, and William Bradford, “the only printer in Philadelphia and a Keithian,” printed it (pp. 487-488). (p. 487-488) The Quaker officials arrested Bradford and the distributor, John McComb, for “printing unlicensed books without including the name of the printer,” confiscated Bradford’s press and type, and withdrew McComb’s license as a retailer (p. 488). (p. 488) Rothbard’s verdict: “The Quaker government might not yet be able to levy taxes, but it was now indeed a government with a vengeance” (p. 488). (p. 488) “And from being the persecuted,” he writes, “the Quakers had now become the persecutors” (p. 488). (p. 488)
Keith protested “the cruel treatment meted out to the two men,” and the government answered with a proclamation against him and, in October, the indictment of three Keithian leaders by a jury Rothbard says was packed with friends of Jennings; they were convicted and fined (p. 488). (p. 488) Bradford got his press back as “one immediately beneficial result” of royal rule under Benjamin Fletcher in 1693, and then left “the inhospitable colony” for New York (pp. 488-489). (p. 488-489)
Rothbard returns to the episode in 1696, when the Quakers who led the Assembly gave Markham his tax bill in exchange for the power to initiate laws: “As the persecution of the Keithians first indicated, the Quakers were beginning to abandon the consistent principles of individual liberty for the alluring perquisites of political power” (pp. 491-492). (p. 491-492)
Additional context beyond the book
Bradford had ended his printing contract with the Philadelphia Quakers on 29 April 1692, so the Keithians’ paper came off his press after that.[2] Born in May 1663, he was twenty-nine that summer.[2] In a later petition he wrote that his “Printing Tools ... had been taken away from me,” and they were lodged in Samuel Jennings’ house.[2] His trial that year, for printing Keith’s broadside without his name in the imprint, ended with the jurors disagreeing.[2]
Jennings later claimed that the sheriff had let Bradford and McComb go home on parole.[2] Bradford said he was held until Governor Fletcher freed him in April 1693.[2] The sheriff, John White, was then ordered to give the printer his tools back.[2]
Why it matters
Interpretation: Freedom to express a view depends partly on access to the tools that carry it. Seizing a press can restrict other people’s ability to encounter an argument as well as the printer’s ability to publish it.
[1][2]
Examine and discuss
Which people and materials were targeted by the authorities?
How would confiscating type affect the circulation of a religious argument?
Compare this seizure with Williams’s banishment: what does each action remove from public discussion?
Read further and reconstruction
Volume I, chapter 64: Government Returns to Pennsylvania. The event and its interpretation are supported by the sources below. Pose, expression, lighting, and composition are artistic choices, not a visual record of the event.
Scene and complete sources: https://freecapitalists.org/books/conceived-in-liberty/episodes/bradford-press-1692/
Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. Source text: CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.
Connecting the scenes: Move to New York in 1735. A jury resists the prosecution of a printer, but an acquittal is not necessarily a lasting change in law.
Scene 4 of 4 · 4 August 1735 · New York City · Volume II, chapter 27
How much can one jury verdict change the limits on criticism of government?
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. New York, 4 August 1735. The jury comes back after a brief deliberation, and the crowded hall answers with three huzzas as printer John Peter Zenger stands at the bar beside Andrew Hamilton. Rothbard is cooler than the legend. In his telling the fight was between two factions of the landed oligarchy, and the law of seditious libel “remained virtually intact.” Chapter 27 of Conceived in Liberty.
Before this scene
John Peter Zenger printed criticism of Governor William Cosby and was jailed before his trial. The accusation was libel, meaning a published statement treated as unlawfully damaging to someone’s reputation. His defense lawyer Andrew Hamilton asked the jury to consider both the truth of the articles and the law used against the printer. The dispute also involved competing political factions. Rothbard praises the defense while warning against turning the acquittal into a simple story of permanent press freedom.
[1][2]
Rothbard’s account
Rothbard says historians have been prone to “wild exaggeration” of John Peter Zenger’s trial, “the best-known and most highly touted case concerning freedom of the press in the colonies” (p. 645). (p. 645)
William Cosby’s arrival as governor in 1732 set off a dispute that Rothbard says was “strictly between two factions of the landed oligarchy” over “extremely petty issues” (p. 645). (p. 645) The Morris faction founded the New York Weekly Journal in 1733 with Zenger as printer, and Rothbard calls its attacks “a bracing exercise of the freedom of the press” (p. 645). (p. 645)
Twice refused a grand-jury indictment, Cosby had Zenger arrested for seditious libel on November 17, 1734, and bail of 400 pounds kept him “in prison for nine months before coming to trial” (p. 646). (p. 645-646) His lawyers were disbarred for protesting Cosby’s packing of the court, and the Morris faction brought in “the venerable Pennsylvania lawyer Andrew Hamilton” (p. 646). (p. 645-646)
The fight against Cosby “was not at root a popular or liberal affair,” Rothbard writes, but the Zenger case transformed it, for “the popular sympathies were all with the defendant” (p. 646). (p. 646) On August 4, 1735, Hamilton won Zenger’s acquittal by persuading the jury to judge the law as well as the facts and by arguing the articles’ truth (p. 646). (p. 646)
“These were legal advances to be sure,” Rothbard writes, “but they hardly justify the paeans of praise that have been delivered for the Zenger decision”: “the root evil—the common law of seditious libel—remained virtually intact” (p. 646). (p. 646) Truth as a defense is “a very shaky reed,” he argues, and juries guard freedom only when public opinion backs the defendant (pp. 646-647). (p. 646-647) English law did not accept the jury’s power to judge guilt until 1792, or truth as a defense until 1843 (p. 647). (p. 647)
Perhaps the most important reason to belittle the case, he argues, is that the main threat to the press was the legislature, which punished critics “without benefit of jury,” and that the Zenger case “made virtually no impact on the legislative oppression of the press even in New York” (p. 647). (p. 647)
Additional context beyond the book
The trial was held in the courtroom on the second floor of City Hall on Wall Street, before Chief Justice James DeLancey and Justice Frederick Philipse.[3][4] When Hamilton argued that the truth of a libel was a defense, DeLancey told him, “The law is clear, That you cannot justify a libel.”[2]
The jury withdrew and came back after a brief deliberation.[2][3] Its foreman, Thomas Bunt in the printed narrative of the case and Thomas Hunt to the New York courts’ historians, answered Not Guilty.[2][3] “Upon which there were three Huzzas in the hall,” the narrative records, “which was crowded with people.”[2]
Zenger was discharged from prison the next day.[2][3] Hamilton was honored with a dinner at the Black Horse Tavern, and cannon saluted him when he left New York.[3]
Why it matters
Interpretation: A jury may protect a particular defendant without settling every future conflict over expression. Distinguishing the outcome of a case from a lasting change in law prevents an attractive origin story from replacing analysis.
[1][2]
Examine and discuss
What did Hamilton ask the jury to consider?
Why does the political rivalry matter when interpreting the trial?
Compare Zenger’s acquittal with Bradford’s confiscated press: what protected expression, and what remained vulnerable?
Scene and complete sources: https://freecapitalists.org/books/conceived-in-liberty/episodes/zenger-verdict-1735/
Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. Source text: CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.
Connect the cases
Compare one religious-dissent scene with one printing scene. Explain the mechanism that restricted expression, the response available, and what the outcome did and did not establish.