Prior knowledge: No prior reading of the book. Know that a colony is a settlement governed under an outside authority; unfamiliar institutions are explained in each scene.
Before you begin
Begin in company-governed Virginia in 1619, move to Massachusetts Bay in the 1630s, then jump to the imperial crisis of the 1770s and Pennsylvania’s constitutional dispute of 1787. These scenes span different governments and more than a century. The gaps are intentional: this is a comparison of authority and consent, not a continuous survey of American history.
What changes when people can elect lawmakers, but a governor and company still hold power?
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Jamestown, 30 July 1619. In the quire of the timber church, some twenty burgesses stand bareheaded in their pews while the minister prays. Governor Yeardley sits in his chair before them. It is the first representative assembly in America. Rothbard says it came hand in hand with the milder laws, part and parcel of easing the Virginia Company’s old tyranny. Chapter 3 of Conceived in Liberty.
Before this scene
Virginia was governed by a company whose earlier rules, known as Dale’s Laws, imposed severe punishments. Governor George Yeardley introduced a milder code before the assembly met. In 1619, elected burgesses, meaning representatives from the colony’s settlements, joined the governor and his council to make laws. Their meeting did not remove the governor’s veto or the company’s authority. Representation created another voice inside an existing system of power; it did not give the assembly unlimited independence.
[1][2]
Rothbard’s account
Rothbard writes that the Virginia colony’s survival “hung, in fact, for years by a hair-breadth,” and credits it in part to “the changes that the company agreed to make in its social structure” (pp. 47-48). (p. 47-48) The company had imposed “communist” principles, which he calls “only an aspect of the harshness of the laws and the government suffered by the colony” (p. 49). (p. 49) Dale’s Laws of 1611, “justly notorious” in his words, punished a third absence from Anglican service with six months in the galleys (p. 50). (p. 50)
Then the company passed to the Puritans, and in 1619 Sir Edwin Sandys, a leader of “the liberal dissent in Parliament,” replaced Sir Thomas Smith as treasurer (p. 50). (p. 50) These “relatively liberal Puritans” sent Sir George Yeardley as governor, and he “at once proceeded to reform the despotic laws of the colony” (p. 51). (p. 51) His milder code of November 1618, “The Great Charter” to the colonists, reduced the penalty for missing church to three shillings and raised each settler’s allotment to fifty acres, “speeding the dissolution of communism” (p. 51). (p. 51)
With that charter Yeardley brought “the first representative institution in America” (p. 51). (p. 51) Six company-appointed councillors sat with burgesses elected by the freemen, two from each of eleven plantations, to make laws and serve as the highest court. (p. 51) But the governor kept a veto, and company edicts “continued to be binding on the colony” (p. 51). (p. 51) The first Assembly met at Jamestown on July 30, 1619, and Rothbard says it “ratified the repeal of Dale’s Laws and substituted the milder set” (p. 51). (p. 51) His conclusion: “The introduction of representation thus went hand in hand with the new policy of liberalizing the laws; it was part and parcel of the relaxation of the previous company tyranny” (p. 51). (p. 51)
The same Assembly, he notes, fixed tobacco’s price by law and ordered “inferior” leaf burned, “the first of continuing attempts by tobacco planters to restrict the supply of tobacco” (p. 52). (p. 52) And he finds it “an ironic commentary” that 1619, “the very year of the Yeardley reforms,” brought the first slave vessel to Jamestown (p. 53). (p. 53)
Additional context beyond the book
Governor Yeardley opened the first General Assembly in the quire of the timber church at Jamestown, which John Pory, the Speaker, called “the most convenient place we could finde to sitt in.”[2][3] The church, built in 1617, was a close-studded timber frame about 50 by 20 feet.[3]
Pory set down how they sat: the governor in his chair with the Council beside him, the Speaker before him with the clerk next to him, and the sergeant standing at the bar.[2] The elected burgesses “tooke their places in the Quire till a prayer was said by Mr. Bucke the Minister,” asking God to guide their proceedings.[2]
The burgesses sat six days, from 30 July to 4 August 1619, and made laws for the colony.[2]
Why it matters
Interpretation: An elected assembly can constrain some forms of power while exercising others. Consider both who gains a voice and what that voice can decide.
[1][2]
Examine and discuss
Which authorities remained above the elected burgesses?
How does the regulation of tobacco complicate the idea that representation necessarily produces freedom?
What further evidence would you need to decide how broadly this assembly represented the colony?
Read further and reconstruction
Volume I, chapter 3: The Virginia Company. The event and its interpretation are supported by the sources below. Pose, expression, lighting, and composition are artistic choices, not a visual record of the event.
Scene and complete sources: https://freecapitalists.org/books/conceived-in-liberty/episodes/first-assembly-1619/
Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. Source text: CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.
Connecting the scenes: Seventeen years later, move from Virginia to Massachusetts Bay. Representation alone does not answer how far government may reach into belief.
Scene 2 of 5 · January 1636 · South of Salem, Massachusetts Bay · Volume I, chapter 21
The sources establish January 1636, not the exact day of departure.
May a government punish a belief because it considers that belief dangerous?
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. The woods south of Salem, January 1636. Banished by Massachusetts for denying that magistrates may punish belief, Roger Williams trudges alone through deep snow. He is three days ahead of the men sent to seize him, and they will find his house empty. Rothbard says the great flight south from the Bay began with him and ended in Providence, a haven of religious liberty. Chapter 21 of Conceived in Liberty.
Before this scene
In Massachusetts Bay, religious disagreement could become a matter for civil authorities. Roger Williams challenged their right to punish religious beliefs and questioned the king’s right to grant land belonging to Native people. The General Court, the colony’s governing assembly and court, ordered him banished in October 1635. He could remain through winter only if he stopped spreading his opinions. When he continued preaching, officials ordered him sent to England. His flight belongs to January 1636; its exact day is unrecorded.
[1][2]
Rothbard’s account
Rothbard calls Roger Williams “an individualist and a fearless logician” who “pursued the Puritans’ logic further than they were willing to go” (p. 173). (p. 173) First Williams denied “the right of the civil authority to punish the infraction of religious rule or doctrine,” which, Rothbard says, “struck at the entire theocratic principle” (p. 173). (p. 173) Then he held that the Indians owned the land and the king had no right to grant it, which hit at the Massachusetts charter itself. (p. 173-174)
Forced once to recant, he took up his doctrines again and became Salem’s chief minister. (p. 174) The authorities condemned his views as “erroneous and very dangerous” and punished Salem by refusing it land at Marblehead Neck (p. 174). (p. 174) When he called on the Salem church to separate from the colony’s other churches, it was, Rothbard writes, “the straw that broke the Massachusetts camel’s back” (p. 174). (p. 174) In September the General Court expelled the Salem deputies and jailed John Endecott until he recanted. (p. 174-175)
In October 1635 Williams “stoutly maintained all of his heretical and libertarian opinions,” and the court ordered him out of the colony within six weeks (p. 175). (p. 175) Over twenty Salem families prepared to follow him south and build “a haven of religious liberty” (p. 175). (p. 175) Should he merely move south, the authorities feared, in Winthrop’s words, “the infection would easily spread” (p. 175). (p. 175) The General Court “hastily sent a ship to Salem to arrest Williams and send him speedily back to England” (p. 175). (p. 175) “But Williams bested his persecutors and fled alone into the wilderness,” trudging south through the snow to winter among “the friendly Narragansett Indians” (p. 175). (p. 175)
In the spring he and four friends founded Seekonk, and more Salem families soon followed: “The great southward flight from Massachusetts had begun” (pp. 175-176). (p. 175-176) Plymouth, not daring to displease Massachusetts, banished him again, and across the Seekonk River he founded Providence, where the settlers “scrupulously purchased the land from the Indians” (p. 176). (p. 176) There, Rothbard writes, Williams lived “free and safe in a Providence enjoying religious liberty and separation of church and state” (p. 176). (p. 176)
Additional context beyond the book
Winthrop wrote that Williams had been given leave to stay until spring on condition that he stop drawing others to his opinions.[2] In January 1636 the governor and assistants learned that he was preaching in his house at Salem to more than twenty followers who meant to plant a settlement on Narragansett Bay, and they ordered him seized and shipped to England.[2] At his house they found he had been gone three days, “but whither they could not learn.”[2]
John Barry writes that the winter was so hard a north-east storm froze even Narragansett Bay.[3] Williams recalled that for fourteen weeks he did not know “what bread or bed did mean.”[3] Long afterward he still wrote of “that Winter snow wch I feele yet.”[3]
Why it matters
Interpretation: Williams’s flight turns a dispute over belief into a dispute over the limits of government. Leaving a jurisdiction may offer refuge while imposing serious costs on the dissenter.
[1][2]
Examine and discuss
Identify a belief Williams held that challenged civil authority.
Why was his continued preaching consequential even after the banishment order?
Compare the authority of this court with the Virginia assembly: what can each institution demand of individuals?
Scene and complete sources: https://freecapitalists.org/books/conceived-in-liberty/episodes/williams-flight-1636/
Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. Source text: CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.
Connecting the scenes: Jump forward more than a century to Boston in 1773. The dispute now concerns imperial and commercial authority rather than the right to remain in one colony.
Scene 3 of 5 · 16 December 1773 · Boston Harbor, Massachusetts · Volume III, chapter 56
When legal authority and local opposition collide, who can decide what happens to a cargo?
Content note: The scene depicts colonists using disguises associated with Native people. The exact identification of those disguises differs across the cited accounts; the picture does not document Native participation.
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Griffin’s Wharf, Boston, the night of December 16, 1773. Men with sooty faces and blankets split East India Company chests and pour the tea over the Dartmouth’s rail. Down on the low-tide mud, apprentices beat it in with staves. To Rothbard the Tea Act was a rescue of the near-bankrupt East India Company that carried its monopoly to American shores. Chapter 56 of Conceived in Liberty.
Before this scene
The Tea Act of 1773 supported the East India Company, a trading company with government privileges. Rothbard emphasizes opposition to its monopoly, an exclusive commercial position protected by government, rather than treating the dispute solely as a tax protest. In Boston, opponents demanded that its tea be sent back without paying duty. Governor Thomas Hutchinson insisted the ships remain until payment. With customs seizure approaching, the dispute moved from meetings and demands to destruction of the cargo on 16 December.
[1][2][4][5][7]
Rothbard’s account
Rothbard reads the Tea Act of May 1773 as a rescue, meant “to relieve the affairs of the East India Company and save it from imminent bankruptcy” (p. 1026). (p. 1026) “The deed that alarmed and provoked the Americans,” he writes, was not the old duty but the move “to extend the hated and feared East Indian monopoly to American shores” (p. 1026). (p. 1026) He rejects the charge of mere self-interest: “Opposition to a governmentally privileged monopoly is itself a high principle” (p. 1027). (p. 1026-1027)
In August 1773 the company moved to “invade the American market,” and the merchants of the four ports and their backers chose the weapon that had beaten the stamps: “revolutionary mob violence or the threat thereof” (p. 1029). (p. 1029) It came to a head in Boston under “the flint-hearted Tory Thomas Hutchinson,” whose published letters had made him “more intransigent than ever,” and whose consignee sons and nephew gave him an interest that “simply strengthened his Tory resolve” (pp. 1029-1030). (p. 1029-1030) Where other officials looked the other way, he “resolved to back the consignees to the hilt” (p. 1030). (p. 1030) The consignees would not resign, the “body” meeting demanded the tea go back untaxed, and Hutchinson kept the ships in port until duty was paid (p. 1030). (p. 1030) After twenty days customs could seize the ships, and the rebels feared officers would “land it, sell it secretly to the people, and use the money to pay the salaries of the appointed officials” (p. 1031). (p. 1031) On December 16, the last chance, Sam Adams gave the signal: “This meeting can do nothing more to save the country” (p. 1031). (p. 1031)
“A remarkably disciplined ginger group of Sons of Liberty, disguised as Mohawk Indians,” spent hours “dumping every bit of East India tea into Boston harbor” (p. 1031). (p. 1031) “No other property and no person was at all harmed,” Rothbard writes, and the band ran “from leading merchants to farmers, carpenters, and blacksmiths” (p. 1031). (p. 1031) No Americans “would help to track down the culprits” (p. 1031). (p. 1031) Many Massachusetts towns backed the Tea Party, many now denying Parliament’s rights “to legislate for and to tax the colonies” (p. 1032). (p. 1032)
Additional context beyond the book
The Dartmouth’s log puts the boarding between six and seven, and Andrews wrote that before nine every chest on the three ships had been knocked to pieces and flung over the sides.[2][5] Thatcher’s Traits records Purkitt and Dolbear on the flats beside one of the vessels at nearly low tide, beating up boxes and tea with tools made of a stave.[4]
Hewes remembered painting his face and hands with coal dust in a blacksmith’s shop.[3] Wyeth remembered ragged clothes and faces smeared with grease and lamp black or soot, and Andrews wrote that the men wore blankets, with their heads muffled and “copper-colored countenances.”[5][7] The Dartmouth’s log counted about a thousand people on the wharf, and Sessions remembered them standing silent.[2][7] Carp writes that Samuel Adams, John Hancock and Joseph Warren stayed at the Old South Meeting House, well away from the wharf.[10]
The Massachusetts Gazette counted three hundred and forty-two chests broken up in three hours, and the East India Company later claimed 9,659 pounds 6s 4d for 340.[6][8] When the tide rose, the Gazette reported, it floated the broken chests and tea all the way from the town to Dorchester Neck.[6]
Why it matters
Interpretation: This confrontation shifts the question from participation within colonial institutions to resistance against imperial authority. A judgment about the destruction should distinguish the protesters’ aims, the property affected, and the alternatives they faced.
[1][2][4][5][7]
Examine and discuss
Why does Rothbard emphasize the company’s commercial privileges?
Which decisions prevented the ships from simply departing?
Compare the demand for a voice in Virginia’s assembly with this challenge to imperial authority: what kind of consent is at issue in each?
Read further and reconstruction
Volume III, chapter 56: The Boston Tea Party. The event and its interpretation are supported by the sources below. Pose, expression, lighting, and composition are artistic choices, not a visual record of the event.
Scene and complete sources: https://freecapitalists.org/books/conceived-in-liberty/episodes/tea-party-1773/
Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. Source text: CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.
Connecting the scenes: Three years later, the argument reaches a vote on independence. A delegate’s journey shows how collective consent depends on representation and attendance.
Scene 4 of 5 · 1 July 1776 · Dover, Delaware, to Philadelphia · Volume IV, chapter 33
How can a representative’s presence change a decision made in the name of a community?
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Delaware, the night of July 1, 1776. A thunderstorm breaks over the road from Dover as Caesar Rodney, wrapped in a green scarf, spurs for Philadelphia. Thomas McKean has sent for him, because Delaware’s two delegates are split on independence. Rothbard says Rodney rode all night to cast the tie-breaking vote. Chapter 33 of Conceived in Liberty.
Before this scene
The Continental Congress brought together delegates from the colonies. On 1 July 1776 it considered a resolution for independence, and Delaware’s two delegates present divided over it. Thomas McKean supported independence and George Read opposed it. A further vote was expected the next day. McKean sent for their fellow delegate Caesar Rodney, who was in Dover. Rodney’s journey connected a distant local representative to a decision in Philadelphia: his arrival could change Delaware’s position without changing either of the other delegates’ views.
[1]
Rothbard’s account
On June 7 Richard Henry Lee submitted “a momentous resolution for the independence of the United Colonies,” and Rothbard writes that for the conservatives “the sticking point was independence” (p. 1289). (p. 1289) The opposition “pretended to favor independence in principle and placed its hopes in postponement” (p. 1290); the radicals came to see the validity of its argument for waiting until the middle colonies had swung into line, and so Congress postponed the question until July 1. (p. 1290)
On July 1, with no firm reply to their request for instructions, New York’s delegates decided to abstain. (p. 1290) Radicals who believed the events of June had met the conservative objections “were in for a rude shock” (p. 1290). (p. 1290) After a fierce debate in the committee of the whole on July 1, Pennsylvania and South Carolina voted against independence, and the two Delaware members present split. (p. 1290) Rothbard charges that the Pennsylvania and South Carolina delegates were “voting their own reactionary wishes in defiance of the will of their constituents,” and calls it “a stunning setback to the radical cause” (p. 1291). (p. 1290-1291)
The next day, July 2, the resolution came to the floor, and he asks, “How was unanimity to be achieved in one day?” (p. 1291). (p. 1291) “Delaware achieved it by sheer energy” (p. 1291): Thomas McKean sent for Rodney in a hurried call. (p. 1291) Rodney, who had been leading militiamen against Tories in southern Delaware, “rode all night in a thunderstorm from Dover to Philadelphia to cast Delaware’s tie-breaking vote for independence” (p. 1291). (p. 1291) South Carolina’s Edward Rutledge, a leader of the fight against independence, announced that he would take his delegation into the camp of independence “for the sake of intercolonial unity” (p. 1291). (p. 1291) Pennsylvania had voted four to three against on July 1, but the next day John Dickinson and Robert Morris “deliberately absented themselves,” and Pennsylvania’s “precarious three-to-two vote for independence made the congressional vote unanimous” (p. 1291). (p. 1291)
“The deed was done,” Rothbard writes: the colonies “were now separate, free, and independent states,” and at last informally united states (p. 1291). (p. 1291)
Additional context beyond the book
On Monday 1 July the question was taken in the committee of the whole, and Delaware’s two delegates present, Thomas McKean and George Read, were divided.[2]
McKean sent an express at his own expense to Dover for Caesar Rodney, who was 47 and lived some eighty miles from the city.[2][3] McKean later recalled meeting Rodney at the State-house door in his boots and spurs as the members were assembling, and going into the Hall of Congress with him.[2] When Delaware’s vote was called, McKean wrote, Rodney rose and said he voted for independence.[2] In his 1814 letter to John Adams, McKean wrote that he met Rodney at the State-house door on the 4th of July, though the committee of the whole had voted on 1 July.[2]
Why it matters
Interpretation: A collective decision depends on rules and participation as well as opinion. Rodney’s ride makes visible how attendance can affect a vote presented as the position of an entire delegation.
[1]
Examine and discuss
Why did Rodney’s arrival matter to Delaware’s vote?
What do the surviving accounts establish about Rodney’s journey, and what parts of the painting remain reconstruction?
Compare the tea protesters’ direct action with a delegate’s vote: how does each claim to speak for a community?
Read further and reconstruction
Volume IV, chapter 33: Independence Declared. The event and its interpretation are supported by the sources below. Pose, expression, lighting, and composition are artistic choices, not a visual record of the event.
Scene and complete sources: https://freecapitalists.org/books/conceived-in-liberty/episodes/rodney-ride-1776/
Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. Source text: CC BY 3.0. External sources retain their own terms.
Connecting the scenes: After independence and the war, move to 1787. The establishment of a new government raises another dispute over how consent is obtained.
Scene 5 of 5 · 29 September 1787 · Philadelphia, Pennsylvania · Volume V, chapter 25
Absent Pennsylvania legislators are forced into the Assembly
Can a decision satisfy a procedural rule while undermining consent?
Content note: The narrative describes legislators seized and forced into a chamber; the reconstruction depicts a blocked attempt to leave.
Modern AI-assisted reconstruction. Philadelphia, September 1787. The Pennsylvania Assembly cannot call a convention to ratify the Constitution without a quorum, so a crowd drags two absent members, James McCalmont and Jacob Miley, from their lodgings into the State House. When McCalmont bolts for the door, the crowd cries “Stop him,” and the men there block his way. Rothbard calls the seizure a monstrous act. Chapter 25 of Conceived in Liberty, Volume 5.
Before this scene
In 1787 the proposed federal Constitution needed ratification, meaning formal approval, through state conventions. Pennsylvania’s Assembly moved to call such a convention. Opponents walked out, leaving it short of a quorum: the minimum number of members required to conduct business. The dispute was over the process for convening a ratification body, not the convention’s final vote itself. Two absent assemblymen, James McCalmont and Jacob Miley, were brought in by force, allowing the Assembly to proceed.
[1][2][4]
Rothbard’s account
In Pennsylvania, Rothbard writes, the radical Constitutionalists of the interior “promised to be a formidable foe” (p. 221). (p. 221) With a majority of 40-28 in the Assembly, “the conservatives acted with ruthless and indecent haste” (p. 221). (p. 221) On September 28 George Clymer proposed calling a ratifying convention on the day Congress decided to transmit the Constitution, “and hence obviously before the Assembly could have received it” (p. 221). (p. 221) The convention elections were called for “the absurdly early date of November 2” (p. 221). (p. 221) Rothbard calls it “clearly an illegal call for a convention—a call made before the Constitution was even received” (p. 221). (p. 221) The radicals, he says, fought valiantly to refer the matter to the forthcoming Assembly and lost by 43-19; finally, “the desperate radicals walked out of the House as this blocked the quorum needed to set the date and conditions for the convention elections” (p. 221). (p. 221)
“At this point,” Rothbard writes, “a monstrous act occurred that added force to the common Federalist tactic of fraud in the ratification contest” (pp. 221-222). (p. 221-222) “A Federalist Philadelphia mob (for all urban centers were heavily Federalist) seized two of the radical defectors,” James McCalmont of Cumberland and Jacob Miley of Dauphin, from the mountainous interior, “and dragged them into the Assembly to make a compulsory quorum” (p. 222). (p. 222) The convention election was called, and the radical minority published an address that, he says, formed the basis for the Pennsylvania Antifederalist position. (p. 222)
“The ugly Philadelphia mob threat loomed once again on election night” (p. 222), when a mob pelted the house of the radical Alexander Boyd with stones and threatened to hang the seven noted Constitutionalists who lived there. (p. 222) The October Assembly elections gave the Republicans a majority of only three, yet by the convention elections in early November the Federalists won 46-23, “the same vote by which the convention eventually ratified the Constitution” (pp. 222-223). (p. 222-223) Rothbard credits the shift to “the superior Federalist organization and propaganda machine, taking advantage of the brief time for debate,” and says more time would have brought greater Antifederalist strength (p. 223). (p. 223)
Additional context beyond the book
On the morning of Saturday, 29 September, the sergeant-at-arms and an assistant clerk were sent to fetch the absent members.[4] They found James McCalmont and Jacob Miley at Major Boyd’s house on Sixth Street, and both refused to come.[2][4] A crowd of Constitution men broke into the lodgings, collared the two and pushed them through the streets to the State House.[2][3][4] They were thrust onto the floor of the House and escorted to their seats, their clothes dirtied and torn, their faces white with anger.[2][3]
The roll was called, and the House had its quorum.[2][4] McCalmont, a major in the war, asked to be excused and offered silver for leave to go, and the House refused.[2][3] He sprang up and made a dash for the door, the crowd yelled “Stop him!” and those about the door barred his way.[2][3] Sixteen of the nineteen members who had walked out signed their address, dated that same Saturday, 29 September.[4]
Jackson Turner Main’s The Antifederalists and Robert L. Brunhouse’s The Counter-Revolution in Pennsylvania give the parallel account of the mob and the quorum.[5][6]
Why it matters
Interpretation: Counting enough members establishes one procedural condition, but does not by itself establish voluntary participation. This scene reopens the question of consent after independence, during the creation of a new government.
[1][2][4]
Examine and discuss
What decision required the Assembly’s quorum?
Why is the forced quorum distinct from the later convention’s vote to ratify?
Connect this case with Rodney’s ride: what difference does voluntary presence make to a representative decision?
Read further and reconstruction
Volume V, chapter 25: The Battle for Pennsylvania. The event and its interpretation are supported by the sources below. Pose, expression, lighting, and composition are artistic choices, not a visual record of the event.
Scene and complete sources: https://freecapitalists.org/books/conceived-in-liberty/episodes/quorum-by-force-1787/
Painting and companion additions: CC BY 4.0, credit freecapitalists.org. Source text: CC BY-NC-ND 4.0; adaptation by permission. External sources retain their own terms.
Connect the cases
Choose at least two scenes and explain when a collective decision does, or does not, count as consent. Identify who decides, who can refuse, and one constraint in each case.